Labour in Global Value Chains: Work Conditions in Football Manufacturing in China, India and Pakistan

Abstract

A critical challenge facing developing country producers is to meet international labour standards and codes of conduct in order to engage in global value chains. Evidence of gains for workers from compliance with such standards and codes remains limited and patchy. This article focuses on the global football industry, a sector dominated by leading global brands that manage dispersed global value chains. It assesses the working conditions for football stitchers engaged in different forms of work organization, factories, stitching centres and home-based settings in Pakistan, India and China. It draws on detailed qualitative primary field research with football-stitching workers and producers in these three countries. The article explains how and why work conditions of football stitchers differ across these locations through an analytical framework that interweaves both global and local production contexts that influence work conditions. In doing so, it argues that current debates on the role of labour in global value chains have to go beyond a narrow focus on labour standards and corporate social responsibility compliance and engage with economic, technological and social upgrading as factors that could generate sustained improvements in real wages and workers' conditions.

Management of Social Issues in Supply Chains: A Literature Review Exploring Social Issues, Actions and Performance Outcomes

“…Despite child labour being used as an effective tool by external stakeholders to target the supply chain of companies, an in-depth discussion is missing in a supply chain context. Few exceptions (Zutshi et al 2009;Lund-Thomsen et al 2012;Nadvi 2008;Kolk and Van Tulder 2002a) emphasise the need to bring changes in the functioning of supply chains by involving both internal and external stakeholders in the process of managing social issues. These changes are brought about by incorporating a wider stakeholder involvement into supply chains, adopting a collaborative approach and installing mechanisms of communication that can build the capacities of suppliers.…”

Corporate Social Responsibility in Global Value Chains: Where Are We Now and Where Are We Going?

“…Multistakeholder initiatives and corporations in the United States instead tend to adopt a more short-term, compliance-oriented approach. Nevertheless, in both the United States and Europe, widespread agreement admits that the compliance-based model has brought about limited improvements in work conditions in developing country export industries (AFL-CIO, 2013;Locke, 2013;Locke et al, , 2009Lund-Thomsen et al, 2012;Ruwanpura, 2012).…”

Governing health and safety at lower tiers of the computer industry global value chain

“…; Lund‐Thomsen et al . ). In apparel, where dismal working conditions continue to result in tragic outcomes, unease on labor compliance has led to industry‐wide initiatives and awareness that process upgrading is often necessary for better worker outcomes (Locke & Romis ; Levi‐Faur & Starobin ).…”