4-Coumaric acid:coenzyme A ligase (4CL) is involved in monolignol biosynthesis for lignification in plant cell walls. It ligates coenzyme A (CoA) with hydroxycinnamic acids, such as 4-coumaric and caffeic acids, into hydroxycinnamoyl-CoA thioesters. The ligation ensures the activated state of the acid for reduction into monolignols. In Populus spp., it has long been thought that one monolignol-specific 4CL is involved. Here, we present evidence of two monolignol 4CLs, Ptr4CL3 and Ptr4CL5, in Populus trichocarpa. Ptr4CL3 is the ortholog of the monolignol 4CL reported for many other species. Ptr4CL5 is novel. The two Ptr4CLs exhibited distinct Michaelis-Menten kinetic properties. Inhibition kinetics demonstrated that hydroxycinnamic acid substrates are also inhibitors of 4CL and suggested that Ptr4CL5 is an allosteric enzyme. Experimentally validated flux simulation, incorporating reaction/inhibition kinetics, suggested two CoA ligation paths in vivo: one through 4-coumaric acid and the other through caffeic acid. We previously showed that a membrane protein complex mediated the 3-hydroxylation of 4-coumaric acid to caffeic acid. The demonstration here of two ligation paths requiring these acids supports this 3-hydroxylation function. Ptr4CL3 regulates both CoA ligation paths with similar efficiencies, whereas Ptr4CL5 regulates primarily the caffeic acid path. Both paths can be inhibited by caffeic acid. The Ptr4CL5-catalyzed caffeic acid metabolism, therefore, may also act to mitigate the inhibition by caffeic acid to maintain a proper ligation flux. A high level of caffeic acid was detected in stemdifferentiating xylem of P. trichocarpa. Our results suggest that Ptr4CL5 and caffeic acid coordinately modulate the CoA ligation flux for monolignol biosynthesis.Lignin is an irreversible, terminal output of a major metabolic pathway in plant secondary metabolism. It is a polyphenolic structural component of the secondary cell walls of vascular plants and plays a unique role in the adaptation of plants to their environment and in resistance to biotic and abiotic stresses (Harada and Cote, 1985). In the formation of secondary cell walls, lignin is deposited between cells (middle lamella) and in cell walls. In the secondary wall, lignin surrounds the hemicelluloses and cellulose, forming a composite of the three major wall components (Timell, 1969;Terashima et al., 2009). Lignin is a major barrier to the utilization of biomass for energy, for papermaking, and for forage digestibility due to its interaction with cellulosics (Sarkanen, 1976;Chiang, 2002;Chen and Dixon, 2007). Studying lignin biosynthesis at the systems or holistic level should lead to better understanding of how the entire biosynthetic pathway is organized and regulated, providing more precise strategies to improve the production of energy, biomaterials, and food.Lignin is typically polymerized from three phenylpropanoid monomers, 4-coumaryl alcohol (metabolite 20 in Fig. 1), coniferyl alcohol (22), and sinapyl alcohol (24), also called the H, G, and S mo...