The hydrogen evolution reaction of HCOOH, CH 3 COOH, and C 2 H 5 COOH solutions consists of two different reduction processes depending on the evaluated potential region; (1) independent reduction of RCOOH and (2) simultaneous reduction of RCOOH and H 2 O. The reduction of each carboxylic acid generates an apparent convective diffusion-controlled limiting current. The first achievement of the present study is that by using a rotating disk electrode (RDE) and a sinusoidal hydrodynamic modulated-rotating disk electrode (SHM), it was elucidated that the additive property of the reduction currents of RCOOH and H 2 O was not effective, and the convective-diffusion current was successfully distinguished from the total current. The second achievement is the successful analysis of the rotation-speed dependency of the limiting current in RDE and SHM using a modified theory of the Koutecky-Levich equation. The slopes of the plots for each carboxylic acid increased in the following sequence: RDE, SHM (p = 0.05), and SHM (p = 0.24), which is consistent with the theory. The dissociation rates of the carboxylic acids and the reverse recombination rate were calculated. The dissociation rates of various carboxylic acids have previously been determined by applying the modified Koutecky-Levich relation 1 based on the rotational-speed dependency of the limiting current for H + reduction at the rotating disk electrode (RDE). [2][3][4] The dissociation rates determined in the previous study 4 were apparently consistent with the results obtained using other methods.5-9 However, we now raise an elementary question about the procedure used for determining the H + -reduction limiting current, which is the basis of the Koutecky-Levich analysis. Based on sinusoidal hydrodynamic modulation (SHM) study, [10][11][12][13][14] we conclude that the potential-dependent limiting current associated with H + -reduction in dilute acid solutions contains a significant potential-dependent current associated with OH − generated simultaneously from the supporting electrolyte. The present SHM analysis of dilute HCl solution and an uncharged weak acid solution, such as formic, acetic, or propionic acid solutions, clearly demonstrates a pure convective diffusion-controlled potential region in addition to that associated with OH − . It is demonstrated that the "limiting" H + -reduction current for formic, acetic, and propionic acids varies considerably with the potential, and pure convective diffusion-controlled potential region could not be determined from the RDE data. Thus, it is likely that the previous studies by other researchers based on RDE 2-4 have somewhat dealt with this issue. This fundamental issue exists for both RDE and SHM data. The present approach for determining the acid dissociation rates requires appropriate choice of an electrode potential that excludes the effect of OH − in the convective diffusion-layer. In this study, we also derive a linear approximation of SHM as well as the RDE theory for determining the rate of dissociation of a...