Kayfabe, Smartdom and Marking Out: Can Pro-Wrestling Help Us Understand Donald Trump?

Abstract

Donald Trump has enjoyed a nearly 30-year relationship with World Wrestling Entertainment as a business partner, fan, in-ring performer and 2013 Hall of Fame Inductee. Noting this long running involvement, it has become a widespread contention that Trump’s style as a political campaigner owes a debt to his experiences within the world of professional wrestling. Taking such claims seriously, this article argues that an engagement with concepts developed within professional wrestling studies would benefit political studies by offering new analytical approaches for the study of the political phenomenon that is Donald Trump. Providing a brief introduction to professional wrestling studies, this article outlines how the concepts of kayfabe, smart fandom and marking out help address a key question for political scholars: how to explain a cynical American electorate’s engagement with and emotional investment in the campaign of such an obvious political fraudster.

Representations of Hulk Hogan in the 1980s: Christianity, Masculinity, Xenophobia

“…Within wrestling itself, the term 'kayfabe' is used to denote the ways in which the performers and managers create illusions and/or deceive the fanbase. Within the industry, kayfabe often implies a one-way relationship whereby the fans (often referred to derogatively as 'marks') are easily duped (Moon 2022). In fact, researchers such as Reinhard (2019) in this area have consistently stressed the symbiotic relationship between performer and fan when it comes to the creation and maintenance of kayfabe.…”

Scholarly Grappling: Collaborative 'Work' in the Study of Professional Wrestling

“…I think professional wrestling is productive for talking about these things. The reason why I, and we, and others, 21 keep returning to things like Donald Trump and kayfabe is because kayfabe is really helpful in making sense of how truthmaking in society and culture operates. 22 Kayfabe is a useful term for understanding advertising or social media influencer culture or celebrity culture and all of these other things.…”