Justice Sites and the Fight against Atrocity Crimes

Abstract

This article develops a new conceptual framework designed to critically study how locality and transversal power relations structure activity and developments in the global field of international criminal justice. The framework is built around the concept of “justice sites,” defined as localities in which organized and social labor—in this case, working with international criminal justice—takes place. The potential effects of social labor performed in specific sites of justice are structured partly by their locality and the resources to which it gives access and partly by their structural position in wider transversal chains of cooperation and competition that cut across different globalized and national fields. In addition to structuring the connections between justice sites, transversal power relations link sites of justice to “practice sites” embedded in other fields in which localized, social labor is not routinely engaged with international criminal justice. Such linkages demonstrate how the framework, developed to study how locality and transversal relations shape the fight against atrocity crimes, can also be used to investigate sites engaged in and across other globalized and national fields of justice, law, governance, and security.

Why Matter Matters: Conflict-Related Sexual Violence and the Relevance of New Materialism

“…Rather than accentuate the agency of institutions, therefore, his sites of justice framework 'points toward a more global, pluralistic, and relational idea of the fight(s) against injustice'. 109 It thus draws crucial attention to the multiplicity of actors and agencies -too often overlooked in Euro-and Western-centric legal discourses -involved in the pursuit of justice.…”