Job Preferences of Nurses and Midwives for Taking Up a Rural Job in Peru: A Discrete Choice Experiment

Abstract

BackgroundRobust evidence on interventions to improve the shortage of health workers in rural areas is needed. We assessed stated factors that would attract short-term contract nurses and midwives to work in a rural area of Peru.Methods and FindingsA discrete choice experiment (DCE) was conducted to evaluate the job preferences of nurses and midwives currently working on a short-term contract in the public sector in Ayacucho, Peru. Job attributes, and their levels, were based on literature review, qualitative interviews and focus groups of local health personnel and policy makers. A labelled design with two choices, rural community or Ayacucho city, was used. Job attributes were tailored to these settings. Multiple conditional logistic regressions were used to assess the determinants of job preferences. Then we used the best-fitting estimated model to predict the impact of potential policy incentives on the probability of choosing a rural job or a job in Ayacucho city. We studied 205 nurses and midwives. The odds of choosing an urban post was 14.74 times than that of choosing a rural one. Salary increase, health center-type of facility and scholarship for specialization were preferred attributes for choosing a rural job. Increased number of years before securing a permanent contract acted as a disincentive for both rural and urban jobs. Policy simulations showed that the most effective attraction package to uptake a rural job included a 75% increase in salary plus scholarship for a specialization, which would increase the proportion of health workers taking a rural job from 36.4% up to 60%.ConclusionsUrban jobs were more strongly preferred than rural ones. However, combined financial and non-financial incentives could almost double rural job uptake by nurses and midwifes. These packages may provide meaningful attraction strategies to rural areas and should be considered by policy makers for implementation.

Human resources for health in Peru: recent trends (2007–2013) in the labour market for physicians, nurses and midwives

“…salary, work hours, prestige, professional development opportunities). Miranda et al [15] and Huicho et al [16] found that in Ayacucho, Peru, physicians were five times more likely, and nurses and midwives 14 times, to choose an urban-based job over a rural one. Incentives that professionals preferred included salary increases and bonus points to gain entry into postgraduate training programmes.…”

Quality of care provided by mid-level health workers: systematic review and meta-analysis

“…Any task-sharing strategy should be implemented alongside other strategies designed to increase the total number of health-care workers. [79][80][81][82] The main obstacle to ensuring that mid-level health workers can help improve health outcomes is that they are often ignored by government policies, health workforce strategies and health system support measures, despite their widespread use. Until these workers are more comprehensively taken into account and supported, their potential contribution will not be fully realized.…”

How to attract health students to remote areas in Indonesia: a discrete choice experiment

“…The Discrete Choice Experiment (DCE) is a quantitative method used to elicit the value of different preferences that influence job choices (World Health Organization et al ., ). DCE is an increasingly popular methodology as a general preference tool and have been used widely in healthcare setting particularly in valuing health worker preferences (Blaauw et al ., ; Huicho et al ., ; Rockers et al ., ). Determining the appropriate policy to effectively recruit and retain health workers can be informed by data from a DCE.…”