“It Was Love in All the Buildings They Tore Down”: How Caregiving Grandmothers Create and Experience a Sense of Community in Chicago Public Housing

Abstract

About 16,000 families residing in Chicago's public housing have been relocated over the last two decades through the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's Housing Opportunities for People Everywhere (HOPE VI) redevelopment initiative. We situate this paper within a larger conversation about the presence and utilization of community ties within public housing despite the territorial stigmatization of traditional public housing. Utilizing in-depth interviews with 20 Black caregiving grandmothers relocated from Chicago public housing we explore how women charged with performing the lion's share of the kinwork needed to ensure family stability experienced and created a sense of community while living in public housing. We show that by providing (1) safety nets for multiple generations, (2) social support and connections to neighborhood institutions, as well as (3) opportunities for Black activist mothering, these women, often at the heart of vertical lineages, created a sense of community amidst the problems in their communities.

The Neighborhood Context of Eviction in Southern California

“…Furthermore, research shows that poor urban residents face eviction and displacement through public policies such as urban renewal and slum clearance that was targeted in predominantly Black neighborhoods (Gans 1962;Hunter 2013) and "poverty deconcentration" initiatives such as public housing demolition (Pattillo 2007;Pittman and Oakley 2018). Not only do these processes disadvantage racial minorities, but African Americans in particular have and continue to experience racial discrimination in lending (Munnell et al 1996) and searching for housing (Turner et al 2013;Yinger 1986), although there is promising evidence that such discrimination is declining over time (Sander, Kucheva, and Zasloff 2018).…”

Relationship to Place for Older Adults in a New York City Neighborhood Undergoing Gentrification: A Discourse Analysis

“…Galcanova and Sykorova (2015) found older adults could navigate neighborhood change while maintaining their identity and sense of place. Other researchers suggest the grandmothers' role provides a sense of community stability and neighborhood mothering (Pittman and Oakley 2018). Attachment to social spaces and neighborhood was found to be meaningful but also a "delicate negotiation of positive and negative aspects, and complex engagement with 'social space' as a profoundly meaningful construct" (Wiles et al 2009, 664).…”