“It’s Pure Panic”: The Portrayal of Residential Care in American Newspapers During COVID-19

Abstract

Background and Objectives This study examines the discursive construction of residential care during the COVID-19 pandemic in three leading American newspapers: The New York Times, USA Today, and The New York Post. Research Design and Methods A total of 54 news articles between 21 January and 8 May 2020 were identified from the LexisNexis academic database for analysis. The articles were analyzed using both a critical discourse analysis approach and a thematic analytical framework. Results Findings indicate that residents’ voices are excluded and superseded by others, namely their family members. Literary elements were used to portray residential care as shockingly dangerous, deceptive, and problematic. Blame was often assigned to an individual or group according to the political tendency of the newspaper. Discussion and Implications A cultural model of panic and dishonesty begins to take shape through the COVID-19 pandemic. Fearmongering and the portrayal of residential care as lacking transparency will likely create future mistrust of the industry. The depiction of vulnerability and the illusion of resident inclusion in the news coverage enable paternalistic decision-making and care practices in the name of supposed protection.

“I Didn’t Meet My Mother; I Saw My Mother”: The Challenges Facing Long-Term Care Residents and Their Families in the Age of COVID-19

“…Hence, not only did many of the settings isolate their residents, but many of the settings also did not openly share information about the pandemic and its impact on residents, resulting in high levels of frustration and distrust among family members. This sense of concealment and limited transparency with regard to LTC settings is not unique to Israel as a recent study conducted in the United States has reported a similar sentiment (Allen & Ayalon, 2020). Their active involvement through banding together to protest against the restrictions and the rupture from the residents speaks to the importance of maintaining an open dialogue between the staff and the family members, and of working in collaboration with them to ensure that the priorities and personal values of the residents, who could not speak up for themselves during the lockdown, are heard and taken into account.…”

The impact of Covid-19-related distancing on the well-being of nursing home residents and their family members: a qualitative study

“…First of all, to avoid extensive distrust and collateral damage in the future, policy makers should openly address the identified issues related to isolation (cf. ( Allen and Ayalon, 2021 )), and collaborate with researchers in developing safe solutions that enable social contact among nursing home residents. Those responsible for designing new interactional protocols in nursing homes should acknowledge the contribution of FMs to the residents' well-being should be acknowledged in changing circumstances (cf.…”

Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on end of life care delivery in care homes: A mixed method systematic review

“…However, there are indications that this evidence is competing with a contrasting, negative narrative that seeks to lay the blame on the staff of care homes for the tragedies that COVID-19 wreaked upon so many residents. 37,38…”