‘It's difficult, I think it's complicated’: Health care professionals’ barriers and enablers to providing opportunistic behaviour change interventions during routine medical consultations

Abstract

Objectives Internationally, public health strategies encourage health care professionals to deliver opportunistic behaviour change interventions. The present study: (1) examines the barriers and enablers to delivering interventions during routine consultations, and (2) provides recommendations for the design of interventions to increase delivery of opportunistic behaviour change interventions. Design Qualitative interview study. Methods Twenty‐eight semi‐structured interviews were conducted with patient‐facing health care professionals. The Behaviour Change Wheel informed a framework analysis in which findings were mapped onto the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF). Intervention functions and behaviour change techniques (BCTs) targeting each TDF domain were identified. Results Health care professionals understood the importance of opportunistic behaviour change interventions (beliefs about consequences), but were sceptical about their capabilities to facilitate behaviour change with patients (beliefs about capabilities). Some clinicians were unwilling to discuss behaviours perceived as unrelated to the patient's visit (social/professional role and identity). Discipline‐specific tasks were prioritized, and delivering interventions was perceived as psychologically burdensome. One‐to‐one contact was favoured over busy hospital settings (environmental context and resources). Seven intervention functions (training, restriction, environmental restructuring, enablement, education, persuasion, and modelling) and eight BCT groupings (antecedents, associations, comparison of outcomes, covert learning, feedback and monitoring, natural consequences, reward and threat, and self‐belief) were identified. Conclusions Across disciplines, health care professionals see the value of opportunistic behaviour change interventions. Barriers related to workload, the clinical environment, competence, and perceptions of the health care professional role must be addressed, using appropriate intervention functions and BCTs, in order to support health care professionals to increase the delivery of interventions in routine practice. What is already known on this subject? Brief, opportunistic interventions can be a cost effective way of addressing population health problems. Public health policies compel health care professionals to deliver behaviour change interventions opportunistically. Health care professionals do not always deliver interventions opportunistically during routine medical consultations; however the barriers and enablers are currently unclear. What does this study add? This is the first study to examine cross‐disciplinary barriers and enablers to delivering opportunistic behaviour change interventions. Across diverse professional groups, working in different medical professions, participants saw the value of delivering opportunistic behaviour change interventions. Targeting key theoretical domains that are shared across professional groups may be useful for increasing the delivery of opportunistic behaviour change...

Delivering Opportunistic Behavior Change Interventions: a Systematic Review of Systematic Reviews

“…The recent health survey for England showed that 32% of patients reported having two out of five behavioral risk factors (in relation to smoking, excess alcohol, diet, physical inactivity, and weight); 19% had three out of five (NHS Digital 2018). Despite this, a recent survey found that healthcare professionals reported delivering behavior change interventions to just 50% of patients who they perceived would benefit from an intervention (Keyworth et al 2019). Thus, the evidence suggests a missed opportunity to deliver behavior change to patients who would benefit, which consequently meets the remit of public health policies, which are designed to encourage healthcare professionals to deliver opportunistic behavior change advice to patients (reference blinded).…”

Exploring womens’ experiences and decision making about physical activity during pregnancy and following birth: a qualitative study

“…This is especially true given that pregnancy is often regarded as a "teachable moment": women may be more open to adopting health behaviours as a result of pregnancy [6]. It is also a time where pregnant women are in regular contact with health providers who are in a position to support health behaviour change with their patients [6,7]. Indeed, for many women, pregnancy may be the only time that they engage with health providers.…”

Perceptions of receiving behaviour change interventions from GPs during routine consultations: A qualitative study

“…One reason for the mismatch between the numbers of patients needing versus receiving behaviour change interventions from their GP concerns barriers to initiating conversations with patients about health behaviour change. These include GP perceptions that patients do not want or need behaviour change interventions [11,12] and beliefs that patients may lack the motivation and are unwilling to make positive behaviour changes [8,13,14]. This results in GPs making conscious decisions about which patients to engage with in discussions about health behaviour [15], based on perceptions of how receptive patients will be to such conversations [16][17][18].…”