It's about time: the evidence for host plant‐mediated selection in the apple maggot fly, Rhagoletis pomonella, and its implications for fitness trade‐offs in phytophagous insects

Abstract

The apple maggot fly, Rhagoletis pomonella, Walsh (Diptera: Tephritidae), provides a unique opportunity to address the issue of host-related fitness trade-offs for phytophagous insects. Rhagoletis pomonella has been controversial since the 1860's when Benjamin Walsh cited the fly's shift from hawthorn (Crataegus spp.) to apple (Malus pumila) as an example of an incipient sympatric speciation event. Allozyme and mark-release-recapture studies have subsequently confirmed the status of apple and hawthorn flies as partially reproductively isolated and genetically differentiated 'host races', the hypothesized initial stage in sympatric divergence. Here, we review the ecological and genetic evidence for host-plant mediated selection in R. pomonella. We reach the following three major conclusions: First, although developmental timing is not everything, it is a good deal of the story. Differences in the fruiting phenologies of apple and hawthorn trees exert different selection pressures on the diapause and eclosion time characteristics of the host races. In particular, the ∼3-week earlier mean fruiting phenology of apples in eastern North America appears to select for a slower rate of metabolism or deeper pupal diapause in apple than hawthorn flies. Second, host-related fitness trade-offs for R. pomonella may not be due to disruptive selection affecting any one specific life-history stage. Rather, it is the sum total of directional selection pressures acting across different life-stages that generates divergent selection on apple and hawthorn flies. For example, selection favors the alleles Me 100, Acon-2 95 and Mpi 37 (or linked genes) in the larval stage in both host races. However, these same alleles are disfavored in the pupal stage to follow, where they correlate with early adult eclosion, and by inference premature diapause termination. Because apple trees fruit an average of ∼3 weeks earlier than hawthorn trees, this counter-balancing selection is stronger on apple-fly pupae. The net result is that the balance of selective forces is different between apple and hawthorn flies, helping to maintain the genetic integrity of the host races in sympatry in the face of gene flow. Finally, natural R. pomonella populations harbor a good deal of genetic variation for development-related traits. This variation allows fly populations to rapidly respond to temporal vagaries in local environmental conditions across years, as well as to broad-scale geographic differences that exist across the range of the species. Perhaps most importantly, this variation gives R. pomonella the flexibility to explore and adapt to novel plants. Taken together, our results underscore how difficult it can be to document host plant-related fitness trade-offs for phytophagous insects due to the need to consider details of the entire life-cycle of a phytophagous insect. Our findings also show how reproductive isolation can arise as a by-product of host-associated adaptation in insects, a central theme for models of sympatric speciation via host...

Genetic and geographic structure of an insect resistant and a susceptible type of Barbarea vulgaris in western Europe

“…Evolution of macro-evolutionary divergence in plant-herbivore interactions has therefore in many cases probably been embedded within an allopatric divergence (Thompson 2005;Nyman et al 2010), and it may be difficult to disentangle these two processes (Rundell and Price 2009). The alternative, that divergence evolved in sympatry, has been suggested for herbivores adapting to specific host plants (Edmunds and Alstad 1978;Feder and Filchak 1999;Dres and Mallet 2002;De Jong et al 2009), but is much less likely in plants due to their requirement for external pollination agents for reproduction.…”

Niche separation in space and time between two sympatric sister species—a case of ecological pleiotropy

“…During the last decades a growing body of evidence has assigned an important role for ecology in speciation and species maintenance (Losos et al 1997;Feder and Filchak 1999;Rundle et al 2000;Schluter, 2000;Hollander et al 2005). In secondary contact zones between recently separated species ecological character displacement driven by interspecific competition is likely to continue the species divergence into less overlapping niches (Schluter 2000).…”

Crop domestication, global human-mediated migration, and the unresolved role of geography in pest control

“…Apple and hawthorn flies show clear evidence for differences in reproductive isolation, host odor preferences, and genetic differentiation throughout the US (Feder and Filchak, 1999;Filchak et al, 2000;Michel et al, 2010). Apple flies emerge an average three weeks earlier than hawthorn flies (Feder and Filchak, 1999).…”