“…It is well known that, when M is one of the constant sectional curvature space forms, such a family g s In this context, Damek-Ricci spaces contrast with the E(k, τ )-spaces with k − 4τ 2 = 0, i.e., the simply connected 3-homogeneous manifolds with isometry group of dimension 4: The products H 2 × R and S 2 × R (τ = 0), the Heisenberg space Nil 3 (k = 0, τ = 0), the Berger spheres (k > 0, τ = 0), and the universal cover of the special linear group SL 2 (R) with some special left-invariant metrics (k < 0, τ = 0). Indeed, in [9], the authors classified all isoparametric hypersurfaces of these spaces, and none of them is spherical. Therefore, for any E(k, τ )-space, k − 4τ 2 = 0, there exist vertical catenoids in E(k, τ ) × R, and none of them is rotational.…”