Is transition experience enough? The donor-side effectiveness of Czech and Polish democracy aid to Georgia

Abstract

The paper examines the democracy aid practices of the Czech Republic and Poland in Georgia. These two countries have recently emerged as promoters of democracy, and have argued that their own transition experience puts them in a unique position to support democratization and the consolidation of democracy in the EU's Eastern Neighbourhood. The paper evaluates how these two countries provide democracy aid to Georgia along three criteria, derived from the aid effectiveness literature: supporting locally driven change, learning from results and coordination. The results indicate that both countries have plenty of space to improve the way their democracy aid is delivered. Neither country has formal systems in place to ensure that they actually support Georgian priorities; evaluations are ad hoc and feedback loops missing; and there is significant scope to improve coordination with other donors. Nonetheless, there seems to be a general perception among stakeholders that the democracy aid provided by the Czech Republic and Poland is relevant to Georgia's needs.

Is Foreign Aid Responsive to Environmental Needs and Performance of Developing Countries? Case Study of the Czech Republic.

“…The leitmotiv of Czech development cooperation is the transfer of Czech "transition experience" to less developed countries [72,73]. This also applies to transfer of environmental know-how, reduction in energy consumption and support of renewable sources of energy [23,24].…”

The Conflict in Eastern Ukraine and International Support for the Decentralization Reform (2014–2022): Theory-Guided Observations

“…Notably, the prevailing geographical focus of development cooperation studies has been Africa, Latin America, and the Caribbean, as well as Southeast Asia, while contributions exploring donor engagement in the post-Soviet space through the development studies lens have been limited. 17 The reasons for this are manifold.…”