Is there a relationship between surgical volume and outcome for total elbow arthroplasty? A systematic review

Abstract

Purpose: Total elbow arthroplasty (TEA) is rarely performed compared to other arthroplasties. For many surgical procedures, literature shows better outcomes when they are performed by experienced surgeons and in so-called ‘high-volume’ hospitals. We systematically reviewed the literature on the relationship between surgical volume and outcomes following TEA. Methods: A literature search was performed using the MEDLINE, EMBASE and CINAHL databases. The literature was systematically reviewed for original studies comparing TEA outcomes among hospitals or surgeons with different annual or career volumes. For each study, data were collected on study design, indications for TEA, number of included patients, implant types, cut-off values for volume, number and types of complications, revision rate and functional outcome measures. The methodological quality of the included studies was assessed using the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale. Results: Two studies, which included a combined 2301 TEAs, found that higher surgeon volumes were associated with lower revision rates. The examined complication rates did not differ between high- and low-volume surgeons. In one study, low-hospital volume is associated with an increased risk of revision compared to high-volume hospitals, but for other complication types, no difference was found. Conclusions: Based on the results, the evidence suggests that high-volume centers have a lower revision rate in the long term. No minimum amount of procedures per year can be advised, as the included studies have different cut-off values between groups. As higher surgeon- and center-volume, (therefore presumably experience) appear to yield better outcomes, centralization of total elbow arthroplasty should be encouraged.

Artroplastia total no tratamento da sequela pós-traumática do cotovelo

“…Mais de 10 procedimentos/cirurgião anualmente e 20 procedimentos/centro parecem diminuir as taxas de revisão e complicação, respectivamente. Portanto, a implementação da regionalização de cuidados complexos e de baixo volume, por exemplo a ATC, reduzem potencialmente os custos dos cuidados de saúde 3,12 .…”

“…A artroplastia total do cotovelo surgiu em meados de 1970 como procedimento restrito às doenças reumáticas avançadas 1,2 . É raramente realizada quando comparada à artroplastia de joelho e quadril, sendo preconizado sua abordagem por cirurgiões experientes em centros de referência 3 .…”