Is the International Criminal Court Unfairly Targeting Africa? Lessons for Latin America and the Caribbean States

Abstract

Africa, Latin America and Caribbean countries share many common features including a history of colonisation, the ongoing fight against human rights abuses and the resultant pursuance of sustainable peace and justice. One of the tools at these countries’ disposal is the International Criminal Court (ICC) where these two blocks are experiencing different fortunes. Except for the Georgia case, all the other cases dealt with by the ICC were from Africa and the court is yet to open an investigation in Latin America and the Caribbean, a situation which allows for lessons for the latter to be drawn from the former’s relationship with the ICC. Using the decolonial perspective I argue that the targeting of Africa by the ICC is part of the colonial project which started with slavery and is now in the coloniality phase. The conclusion is that willingly or unwillingly, the way the ICC has treated Africa is tantamount to targeting. This perception can only be changed if the ICC successfully opened new cases elsewhere, especially in the west.

Timing of transitional justice mechanisms and the implications for the South Sudan peace process

“…Africa and the International Criminal Court (ICC) have featured prominently in recent discourses on international criminal justice (Sunga 2014, Benyera 2018, Chipaike et al 2019. The ICC-Africa question is complex and perforated with controversies.…”

Understanding South Africa’s Changing Positions on International Criminal Justice: Why the country wanted to withdraw from the International Criminal Court (ICC) and why it may remain in the ICC for the time being?1

“…There is a wider context to the issues concerning the way the AU views the ICC (Sarkin, 2016a). There have long been allegations of bias on the part of the ICC (Austin & Thieme, 2016) against Africa (Benyera, 2018), but more recent has been the view that the ICC is a neo-colonialist institution (Labuda, 2014) doing the bidding of the Global North (Maklanron, 2016). It has also been asked why African states should be held accountable when many of the powerful states including the USA, Russia, China, India, etc.…”

The Complexities of South African Xenophobia on Nigerian Nationals

“…Their relationship became sour when Nelson Mandela pursued international sanctions on the regime of General Sani Abacha. However, the golden age of bilateral relations was initiated after 1999 by president Obasanjo and Mbeki, promoting new African institutions and developing efforts to strengthen the diplomatic ties between the two (Benyera, 2018). Both country's high commissioners had relatively been allowed access to their host presidents.…”