Is migration from Central and Eastern Europe an opportunity for trade unions to demand higher wages? Evidence from the Romanian health sector

Abstract

Industrial relations scholars have argued that east-west labour migration may benefit trade unions in Central and Eastern Europe. By focusing on the distributional aspect of wage policies adopted by two competing Romanian trade unions in the health care sector, this article challenges the assumption of a virtuous link between migration, labour shortages and collective wage increases. We show that migration may also displace collective and egalitarian wage policies in favour of individual and marketized ones that put workers in competition with one another. Thus, the question is not so much whether migration leads to wage increases in sending countries, but whether trade unions' wage demands in response to outward migration consolidate collective solidarity and coordination in wage policy-making, or support its individualization and commodification.

Offshoring, labour migration and neo-liberalisation: nationalist responses and alternatives in Eastern Europe

“…The opening of the borders and mass emigration of Polish workers after 2004 have led to the outflow of workers from some industries and an increase in wages (Hardy, 2009, chapter 10). As Stan and Erne (2016) argue, workforce outflows from Eastern European markets do not necessarily mean that wages will automatically grow in Eastern Europe. Migration may also displace collective and egalitarian wage policies in favour of individual and marketised ones that put workers in competition with one another.…”

“…The collapse of the Eastern Bloc intensified labour migration from Eastern to Western Europe Mass migration from this region is less often attributed to austerity policy and financial crisis than to the integration of the Eastern and Western economies, the neo-liberal transformation in Eastern Europe and the integration of capitalism (Stan and Erne, 2016). Enlargement of the EU in 2004 through the accession of new Eastern European member states opened up new possibilities for intra-EU labour migration.…”

Employee Relations in Context: Globalization, Uncertainties, and Dynamics of Change

“…Although increased emigration led to a tighter labour market in Eastern Europe, it generally triggered wage increases only for managers and highly skilled professionals, as migrant workers from further east filled lower skilled jobs (e.g. Ukraine, Moldova, China and Vietnam) (Stan and Erne, 2015). Migrant workers are more likely to accept lower wages (and jobs below their qualifications) than non-migrant workers, as wages in their home country are often significantly lower than in the host countries (e.g.…”

Trade union strategies in the age of austerity: The Romanian public sector in comparative perspective

“…1993-1997 1998-2002 2003-2007 2008-2012 2012-2016 Education Healthcare differences in association power resources, healthcare unions have also followed different discursive strategies towards austerity and healthcare reforms. Importantly, whereas in the aftermath of the economic crisis Sanitas has consistently argued for a fairer distribution of wages across the healthcare sector and advocated for wage increases for low-paid workers, Solidaritatea Sanitara has followed a more individualistic agenda, which emphasised performance-based-pay and reflected the narrow interests of its constituency which was primarily made of doctors (Stan and Erne 2016). Still, by 2018, this cleavage in the sector seems to be less evident as Solidaritatea Sanitara has gradually shifted its position closer to that of Sanitas especially on the contentious issue of capping bonus levels.…”