Is Europe 2020 Set to Fail? The Cultural Political Economy of the EU Grand Strategies

Abstract

The European Union (EU) has been continuously rethinking its global position amidst emerging economic and geopolitical challenges and attempting to formulate strategies to increase its competitiveness. However, its long-standing policy implementation deficit is also recognized for its grand strategies, including the initially ambitious Lisbon Strategy. Is Europe 2020 set to fail as well? In this paper, we are arguing that strategic steering is essentially a discursive practice influenced by both semiotic and extra-semiotic factors. Hence, success or failure of a strategy essentially depends on ability to steer the discourse. Niklas Luhmann's social systems theory offers a theoretical framework against which limitations and potentials of strategic steering at the EU level can be analysed. While high levels of rationality and reflection capacities can improve strategic steering, it is limited by the increasing complexity. Recognizing limitations of direct and centralized interventions, we look for analytical and strategic solutions in sophisticated mechanisms of contextual steering: variation, selection and retention of strategic discourses. These mechanisms are integral to the "cultural political economy" approach. In the final part of the paper, we show how cultural political economy can explain the implementation shortcomings of the EU strategies.

The implementation of the Strategy Europe 2020 objectives in European Union countries: the concept analysis and statistical evaluation

“…The Lisbon Strategy, from the substantive perspective, was not a new initiative, as before there had been attempts to introduce various processes in order to recover and reorganise the functioning of the EU. However, its versatility and realisation of comprehensive and integrated attitude to the socio-economic and environmental problems by retaining the principle of subsidiary was innovative (Dearden 2008 ; Makarovic et al 2014 ). The Lisbon Strategy objective was to create the EU’s economy based on knowledge by Lisbon Strategy ( 2002 ): creating an information society, creating a European area for research and innovation, creating an environment favourable for developing the innovative entrepreneurships (especially small and medium enterprises), integrating financial markets, coordinating macroeconomic policies, fiscal consolidation, quality and sustainability of public finances.…”

The European Commission and Europe 2020: smart, sustainable and inclusive growth

“…(Eurostat, 2017: 8) Europe 2020 is soon to be concluded after a decade of embedded initiatives and flagships for European governance to be implemented. There Tusińska, 2016;Makarovič et al, 2014;Gros and Roth, 2012;Prijon, 2012;Borghetto and Franchino, 2010). Many other scholars have provided different forecasts pointing out more or less progress to be expected on R&D, employment, education, climate, poverty reduction and so on (see Gros and Roth, 2012: 2-4).…”

Economic and social security in EU: Reforming Slovenian law on social enterpreneurship

“…Generally speaking, the negative effects of neoliberal policies have since long contributed the focus on social quality aspects of development (Fairweather et al 2001) and related approaches, including social entrepreneurship, which is spreading at a rapid pace in the entire Europe. Taking mediocre implementation record of the EU grand strategies into account (Makarovič et al 2014), it can play important role in implementation of the recent Europe 2020. The social economy offers new possibilities for the innovative employment of vulnerable target groups aiming to enable companies of this kind to independently generate revenue and survive (Trampuš, Cankar and Setnikar Cankar 2013).…”