Is Distance Really Dead? Comparing Industrial Location Patterns over Time in Canada

Abstract

This article presents a model for comparing industrial location patterns over time, applied to Canadian data for 1971 and 1996. The Canadian economy is divided into eighteen industrial sectors (manufacturing and services), of which eight are examined in detail. The analysis addresses several questions. Do observed location models for given industries follow predictable patterns? How stable are those patterns over time? Has the relative sensitivity to "distance" of given industries changed over time? Can significant breaks in location patterns be observed over time? The authors consider the possible impact of information technology on location. If "distance is dying," as is sometimes argued, this should be reflected in changing location patterns. The results show a high degree of stability over time, suggesting that distance is still very much alive.

Industry life cycles of a resource town in Finland – the case of Lieksa

“…At the regional level, the transformation to a knowledge economy, which is urban-centric, is most problematic in remote rural areas, which are heavily dependent on inadequate regional assets and human skills (Kangasharju and Pekkala, 2004). Similarly, rural areas close to the largest cities in Canada have succeeded better than other rural areas in compensating for employment losses in the primary industries, as they have benefited from commuting to the regional cores (Partridge et al, 2007;Polèse and Shearmur, 2004). Economic wealth occurs unevenly geographically as a result of stagnant or declining demand and poor competiveness for economic diversification.…”

The Power of Place: A Case Study of Auckland’s Design Creative Industries

“…The places where clusters locate are also different for different industries [19]. A significant body of literature presents arguments that the "power of place" continues to exert an influence [22], "distance is still very much alive" [23], and "place remains the central axis of our time" despite the realities of the global economy dominated by technological advancements, the World Wide Web, and high speed telecommunications [24]. The "death of distance" argument with regard to the creative economy [22,25] and the assertion that "the city will dissolve in the Internet" [26] have proven groundless despite worldwide digitalisation and globalisation trends and advancements in ICTs.…”

On the Difficulty of Comparing the Spatial Distribution of Service Industries Across Nations: Contrasting Spain and Canada

“…The five largest urban areas have comparable populations; we may thus reasonably assume that associated agglomeration economies are not dramatically different and that the city size variable measures comparable realities. In addition to population data, urban areas in both nations wi th less than 500,000 inhabitants are classified according to distance from a larger metropolis, using a scheme employed in previous studies (Polèse and Shearmur 2004, Polèse, Rubiera, and Shearmur 2007. For Spain, observations are also classified as coastal/ interior and as administrative capitals (or not) of provinces or autonomous communities.…”