The structures of all plausible isomers of the
SiC2H7
+ ion were optimized at the
SCF and
correlated levels of theory, including the MP2/6-31G** and the
B3LYP/6-31G** methods.
At all levels of theory the most stable isomer was found to be
(CH3)2SiH+ (1).
At the SCF
level the next was
C2H5SiH2
+
(2), lying ca. 21 kcal/mol higher, followed by the
symmetric
SiH3-bridged
H3SiCH2CH2
+,
which can also be regarded as an addition/elimination
complex
of SiH3
+ and C2H4
(5 is ca. 24 kcal/mol higher than 1). Two
other isomers,
CH3SiH2CH2
+
(3) and
CH3SiH3CH+
(4) lie significantly higher. However, at the
B3LYP/6-31G** level 3 is
no longer a stationary point. No transition state was found for
the direct interconversion of
1 and 2. It is proposed that this
experimentally observed interconversion occurs through
5.
The corresponding transition state (TS1) has a
C
s
symmetry and corresponds to
the
symmetric shift of two hydrogens. At the SCF levels it lies higher
than SiH3
+ + C2H4,
but
at correlated levels it becomes several kcal/mol lower, thus allowing
isomerization before
dissociation. Other transition states connecting 5 with
2 through 4 lie lower than TS1
at
all levels of theory. The symmetric nature of the TS1
transition state may account for the
observed differences in the exchange reactions of
CH3SiH2
+ and
(CH3)2SiH+ with
deuterated
ethene.