Involving people with learning disabilities in research: issues and possibilities

Abstract

Advances in the social position of people with learning disabilities have led to a situation where research and evaluation studies are increasingly required to include the views and opinions of people with learning disabilities. One key outcome of this shift is that some of the major funding bodies now insist on the inclusion of people with learning disabilities as a condition of research funding. This has produced new possibilities and new challenges for researchers, and it has real consequences for people working in health and social care. The present paper sets out to explore some of the developments and challenges in research with people with learning disabilities. The author provides a selective overview of developments with the aim of demonstrating the richness, ingenuity and potential of research involving people with learning disabilities. The paper is divided into three broad sections that focus on: (1) the ethics and philosophy of participatory research; (2) the methodologies employed at particular points in the research process that are designed to ensure the involvement of participants in research; and (3) building capacity in participatory research as a precondition to the further development of this approach. An investment in capacity would enable this approach to move into the mainstream of research activity involving people with learning disabilities.

Exploratory Study on Drug Users’ Perspectives on Quality of Life: More than Health-Related Quality of Life?

“…One of the biggest challenges in measuring QoL is trying to capture the uniqueness of this concept for each individual (Padaiga et al 2007), which means that it is not always desirable to start from an objective standard of QoL. Many standardized instruments start from professionals' definition of what they think is important for a good QoL and are not based on clients' or patients' own life experiences (Gilbert 2004). This might result in a ''tyranny of quality'' (Goode and Hogg 1994) when QoL is conceptualised in such a structured way, that it ignores individual experiences.…”

“…For future research, it would be useful to make a shift from participative to emancipatory research (Gilbert 2004). In participative research, researchers and participants collaborate, but the bulk of responsibility and decision-making rests with the researcher (Walmsley 2001).…”

«Design for All» in Social Research on Persons with Disabilities

“…These types of methodologies for the social study of disability have been conceptualised in the English-language literature as 'inclusive research', and applied more frequently to groups with cognitive disabilities (Gilbert, 2004;Walmsley, 2004). In these studies, persons with disabilities participate in all stages of the research process, from the initial defi nition of goals to the drafting of the fi nal report and dissemination of results, and may also be involved in managing and leading the process (Boland et al, 2007).…”

How can we confidently judge the extent to which student voice in higher education has been genuinely amplified? A proposal for a new evaluation framework

“…Transformation is conceptualised rather differently in the participatory research literature. Participation is argued to bring about changes in the power relationships (French and Swain 2004;Gilbert 2004); changes in attitude; changes in funding priorities (Duckett and Pratt 2001) or changes in practice. The emphasis within participatory research on owning the research, sharing power, as well as having control and choice means that participatory research is strongly linked to empowerment.…”