Investigation of Legionella Contamination in Bath Water Samples by Culture, Amoebic Co-Culture, and Real-Time Quantitative PCR Methods

Abstract

We investigated Legionella contamination in bath water samples, collected from 68 bathing facilities in Japan, by culture, culture with amoebic co-culture, real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR), and real-time qPCR with amoebic co-culture. Using the conventional culture method, Legionella pneumophila was detected in 11 samples (11/68, 16.2%). Contrary to our expectation, the culture method with the amoebic co-culture technique did not increase the detection rate of Legionella (4/68, 5.9%). In contrast, a combination of the amoebic co-culture technique followed by qPCR successfully increased the detection rate (57/68, 83.8%) compared with real-time qPCR alone (46/68, 67.6%). Using real-time qPCR after culture with amoebic co-culture, more than 10-fold higher bacterial numbers were observed in 30 samples (30/68, 44.1%) compared with the same samples without co-culture. On the other hand, higher bacterial numbers were not observed after propagation by amoebae in 32 samples (32/68, 47.1%). Legionella was not detected in the remaining six samples (6/68, 8.8%), irrespective of the method. These results suggest that application of the amoebic co-culture technique prior to real-time qPCR may be useful for the sensitive detection of Legionella from bath water samples. Furthermore, a combination of amoebic co-culture and real-time qPCR might be useful to detect viable and virulent Legionella because their ability to invade and multiply within free-living amoebae is considered to correlate with their pathogenicity for humans. This is the first report evaluating the efficacy of the amoebic co-culture technique for detecting Legionella in bath water samples.

Water Quality Study on the Hot and Cold Water Supply Systems at Vietnamese Hotels

“…Some studies have detected the presence of Legionella bacteria in hot water supply systems [6][7][8][9]. One study also found that there was Legionella bacteria in a filled tub in a Japanese bathing facility.…”

Prevalence ofmipvirulence gene and PCR-base sequence typing ofLegionella pneumophilafrom cooling water systems of two cities in Iran

“…9 In other study, more than 1100 cases of legionellosis in Japan, caused by contaminated artificial whirlpool spas or natural hot springs were presented in Infectious Agents Surveillance Report 2014. 10 Only a few factors have been detected and characterized that contribute to survival of the L. pneumophila in eukaryotic cells. The macrophage infectivity potentiator (mip) gene is described as a virulence factor necessary for optimal intracellular survival of this bacterium.…”

Comparing Efficiency Between Conventional and Molecular Methods for Detecting Legionella pneumophilia in Dental Unit Waterline Systems

“…Real Time PCR can also determine the presence of non-cultivable Legionella spp., especially VBNC types [15]. Our results have shown that real-time PCR was more sensitive and less time consuming to detect the L. pneumophilia in water samples.…”