“…This debate has not subsided in the presence of large population-based studies that have failed to demonstrate excess risk associated with home birth (3)(4)(5)(6)(7)(8)(9)(10)(11)(12). Controversy continues, given the absence of randomized controlled trials and inability to draw conclusions from observational studies because outcomes are attributed to actual versus planned place of birth (13)(14)(15), difficulty in ascertainment of qualifications of caregivers (16), nonrepresentative sampling (8,9), lack of an appropriate comparison group (3,9,11), inadequate statistical power (4,10), inability to exclude unplanned home births from the study sample (4,16,17) inability to sort out the effect of place of birth as opposed to the type of caregiver (18,19), and differing qualifications of midwives (lay versus direct entry versus nursemidwives) (4).…”