Investigating the relationship between welfare and rearing young in captive chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes)

Abstract

a b s t r a c tWhether the opportunity to breed and rear young improves the welfare of captive animals is currently debated. However, there is very little empirical data available to evaluate this relationship and this study is a first attempt to contribute objective data to this debate. We utilized the existing variation in the reproductive experiences of sanctuary chimpanzees at Chimfunshi Wildlife Orphanage Trust in Zambia to investigate whether breeding and rearing young was associated with improved welfare for adult females (N = 43). We considered several behavioural welfare indicators, including rates of luxury behaviours and abnormal or stress-related behaviours under normal conditions and conditions inducing social stress. Furthermore, we investigated whether spending time with young was associated with good or poor welfare for adult females, regardless of their kin relationship. We used generalized linear mixed models and found no difference between adult females with and without dependent young on any welfare indices, nor did we find that time spent in proximity to unrelated young predicted welfare (all fullnull model comparisons likelihood ratio tests P > 0.05). However, we did find that coprophagy was more prevalent among mother-reared than non-mother-reared individuals, in line with recent work suggesting this behaviour may have a different etiology than other behaviours often considered to be abnormal. In sum, the findings from this initial study lend support to the hypothesis that the opportunity to breed and rear young does not provide a welfare benefit for chimpanzees in captivity. We hope this investigation provides a valuable starting point for empirical study into the welfare implications of managed breeding.

Seasonal, Diel, and Age Differences in Activity Budgets of a Group of Bottlenose Dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) Under Professional Care

“…The second most abundant behavior following low intensity swim was low intensity play. In one study, play has been referred to as a luxury behavior (e.g., Cronin, West, & Ross, 2016) likely due to the fact that play is initiated when an animal has no competing systems such as feeding, mating or predator avoidance (Burghardt, 2005). For many species in the wild, play behavior is often lower than 10% of an animal's activity budget (Burghardt, 1984, Burghardt, 1988.…”

A review of research in primate sanctuaries

“…Measures of the welfare of sanctuary-housed primates have also received considerable research attention. Broad chimpanzee welfare assessments [71][72][73], as well as studies focusing royalsocietypublishing.org/journal/rsbl Biol. Lett.…”

Stress behaviors in captive robust capuchins: Effects of humidity, visitors, management and sex

“…Females expressed both types of stress behaviors at higher rates than males. They likely exhibited higher rates of stereotypes because they were more frustrated with free time without alternatives to allocate it, as they are more motivated to forage, travel, and engage in maternal activities (Back et al, 2019;Fragaszy, 1986), though some studies did not find significative behavioral differences in captive primates with or without offspring (e.g., Cronin et al, 2016).…”