Marine
and lacustrine shales are two major important types of organic-rich
shales that are usually deposited in the stable ocean basin and deep
lake/swamp settings, respectively. In the past decade, commercial
development of marine shale gas resources has been achieved. The underdeveloped
lacustrine shale also showed great oil and gas potential. Is it feasible
to simply copy the development mode of marine shale gas to lacustrine
shale? This is what this paper would attempt to answer from the viewpoint
of rock mechanics. Using borehole cores from two typical marine and
lacustrine shale gas wells, a series of experiments, including X-ray
diffraction (XRD), triaxial compression, fracture surface three-dimensional
(3D) scanning, and scanning electron microscopy (SEM), were implemented
to comprehensively reveal the mechanical difference between marine
and lacustrine shales. Postfailure fracture complexity and surface
roughness were quantified by fractal dimension and morphology reconstruction,
respectively. A new index BInew, considering the influences
of the complete stress–strain curve and fracture characteristics,
was proposed to evaluate the brittleness of these two types of shales.
Results showed that the mechanical properties of marine and lacustrine
shales were quite different and should be exploited by following their
own characteristics. Mechanical parameters of lacustrine shale, such
as compressive strength, Young’s modulus, cohesive strength,
and internal friction angle, were much lower than those of marine
shale. Different from the typical shear plus bedding splitting failure
mode of marine shale, lacustrine shale usually formed only one smooth
shear fracture. Based on the newly proposed index, the brittleness
of lacustrine shale was significantly lower than that of marine shale.
Huge discrepancy in quartz and clay mineral contents and the consequent
petrophysical structure divergence were the reasons for the marked
mechanical difference between marine and lacustrine shales. Differentiation
strategies and effects of hydraulic fracturing for these two kinds
of formations were also discussed.