Investigating the glass ceiling phenomenon

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to identify hurdles in women’s rise up the organizational ladder through the epistemic concept of the glass ceiling phenomenon. The secondary aim is to determine how the glass ceiling effect results in women’s failure to secure equal representation in high-ranking executive positions in comparison to males. The study intends to come up with empirical evidences to advance plausible justifications and support for the organizations to manage their workforce with the sense of egalitarianism. Design/methodology/approach The questionnaire is administered to a sample of 210 respondents including CEOs, directors, managers, assistants, accountants, doctors and teachers from public and private sectors. The variables that influence the glass ceiling phenomenon are gender (female) represented on the board of directors (BODs), stereotypical behavior and training and development of females to measure the glass ceiling effect. Further, this influence is examined regarding the selection and promotion of the females as candidates, as well as female effectiveness at work. To verify the glass ceiling phenomenon, multiple linear regression analyses with the ordinary least square method are used. Findings Drawing on the perspective of the social role theory, the authors identify plausible causes of the glass ceiling phenomenon in the Asian context. The results show the presence of glass ceiling, particularly characterizing its effects on the selection and promotion of the female candidates and their effectiveness. The authors found that glass ceiling was negatively related to both female effectiveness and “selection and promotion.” It was also identified that research variables such as lesser women’s representation on the BODs, training and development and stereotypical attitude toward women promote glass ceiling. Research limitations/implications The larger sample and data collection from different cultures would have assured more generalizability. The glass ceiling is affected by numerous variables; other factors can also be explored. Practical implications Organizations must consider competitive females in their selection and promotion decision making. Asian countries, especially developing countries such as Pakistan, need to develop policies to encourage active participation of the female workforce in upper echelon. The equal employment policies will reduce the dependency ratio of females, consequently driving the country’s economic growth. Social implications Societies need to change their stereotype attitudes toward women and encourage them to use their potential to benefit societies by shattering glass ceilings that continue to place women at a disadvantage. Developing a social culture that advances women empowerment will contribute to social and infrastructure development in Asian countries. Originality/value This paper adds a thought-provoking attitude of organizations in South Asia, especially in Pakistani societies that play a role in creating a glass ceiling, more so to shatter it even in 2016. This study compels firms in Pakistan and other Asian regions to use unbiased practices by investigating the impact of glass ceiling on female effectiveness that has not previously been conducted in the Asian context. To the best of the authors’ knowledge, the study of glass ceiling in Pakistani context is first in the literature.

Women on top: the career development journey of Filipina business executives in the Philippines

“…Culture and gender roles in the Asian workplace Culture or "the collective programming of the mind" separates and situates groups of individuals from each other (Hofstede, 1984, p. 51;Khlif, 2016, p. 547), as well as shapes and influences gender roles in organizations and societies (Saleem et al, 2017). For example, Asian women are customarily viewed to be in charge of one's household, maintaining its upkeep and ensuring the needs of the children as provided for by the salaries of men (UN, 1994;UNIFEM, 2005).…”

Development and Validation of Patriarchal Beliefs Scale in Pakistani Culture

“…Pakistani women do not, however, benefit from the privilege that Islam has bestowed upon them. Despite having the knowledge and abilities needed for leadership positions, it is argued that Pakistani women are restricted by societal glass ceilings and systemic gender discrimination in the workplace and in private settings (Saleem, et al, 2017). Like other Muslim communities, Pakistan's social and religious functions sometimes overlap, making it difficult to separate them and classify them as domestic versus public (Shah, 2006).…”

The Creation of Tradition and the Alteration of Social Structure by the Mystic Baul Fakir Lalon Shah

“…A minimum of one female director must be appointed to the board of directors of listed companies and certain other public corporations, according to Section 149(1) of the Companies Act, 2013 [1]. Companies registered under the Companies Act of 2013 must abide by this requirement within six months of the date of establishment.In order to give women job possibilities while taking into consideration the difficulties they face at work, the Promotion of Women's Participation and Advancement in the Workplace Act was put into effect in 2016.…”