Investigating the Congruence of Crowdsourced Information With Official Government Data: The Case of Pediatric Clinics

Abstract

BackgroundHealth 2.0 is a benefit to society by helping patients acquire knowledge about health care by harnessing collective intelligence. However, any misleading information can directly affect patients’ choices of hospitals and drugs, and potentially exacerbate their health condition.ObjectiveThis study investigates the congruence between crowdsourced information and official government data in the health care domain and identifies the determinants of low congruence where it exists. In-line with infodemiology, we suggest measures to help the patients in the regions vulnerable to inaccurate health information.MethodsWe text-mined multiple online health communities in South Korea to construct the data for crowdsourced information on public health services (173,748 messages). Kendall tau and Spearman rank order correlation coefficients were used to compute the differences in 2 ranking systems of health care quality: actual government evaluations of 779 hospitals and mining results of geospecific online health communities. Then we estimated the effect of sociodemographic characteristics on the level of congruence by using an ordinary least squares regression.ResultsThe regression results indicated that the standard deviation of married women’s education (P=.046), population density (P=.01), number of doctors per pediatric clinic (P=.048), and birthrate (P=.002) have a significant effect on the congruence of crowdsourced data (adjusted R 2=.33). Specifically, (1) the higher the birthrate in a given region, (2) the larger the variance in educational attainment, (3) the higher the population density, and (4) the greater the number of doctors per clinic, the more likely that crowdsourced information from online communities is congruent with official government data.ConclusionsTo investigate the cause of the spread of misleading health information in the online world, we adopted a unique approach by associating mining results on hospitals from geospecific online health communities with the sociodemographic characteristics of corresponding regions. We found that the congruence of crowdsourced information on health care services varied across regions and that these variations could be explained by geospecific demographic factors. This finding can be helpful to governments in reducing the potential risk of misleading online information and the accompanying safety issues.

Trends of infodemiology studies: a scoping review

“…Although some contemporary studies address both the demand based and supply based approaches (Bragazzi, Dini, Toletone, Brigo & Durando, ; Bragazzi, Watad, et al., ; Brigo & Erro, ; Lampos, Yom‐Tov, Pebody & Cox, ; Nagar et al., ; Santos & Matos, ). The last group is categorised as ‘other studies’ in which no Web tools were used (Chen et al., ; Kim, Jung, Jung & Hur, ; Kind et al., ; Liu et al., ; Showghi & Williams, ).…”

“…Based on The United Nations’ country classification (United Nations, ), the findings indicated that 46 (82%) articles were related to developed countries, as shown in Table , while seven (12.5%) were related to developing countries (Chan, Ho & Lam, ; Chen et al., ; Kim et al., ; Liu et al., ; Ocampo, Chunara & Brownstein, ; Wang et al., ; Wong et al., ). Three demand based articles (5%) belong to Russia as a country in transition (Domnich et al., ; Zheluk, Quinn, Hercz & Gillespie, ; Zheluk, Quinn & Meylakhs, ).…”

Mobile-Friendly Dashboards to Display Associations Between Cited-by and Similar Journals on Mobile Health Research: A Bibliometric Study (Preprint)

“…The Kendall coefficient (W) [24][25][26][27][28][29] was used to assess the concordance among to judge the concordance. The significance level is set at 0.05.…”

Help-seeking behaviour and attitudes towards internet-administered psychological support among adolescent and young adults previously treated for cancer during childhood: protocol for a survey and embedded qualitative interview study in Sweden

“… 54 Indeed, there is some indication e-MH resources are not widely accessed by young people. 55 One potential difficulty may be related to what has been coined the ‘ technology push’ , whereby e-MH solutions are designed to fit available technology, rather than to meet the unmet needs and preferences of end-users. 56 Furthermore, research indicates poor uptake and ongoing use of e-MH interventions that have been implemented into healthcare settings within the general population.…”