Investigating Psychological Differences Between Nurses and Other Health Care Workers From the Asia-Pacific Region During the Early Phase of COVID-19: Machine Learning Approach

Abstract

Background As the COVID-19 pandemic evolves, challenges in frontline work continue to impose a significant psychological impact on nurses. However, there is a lack of data on how nurses fared compared to other health care workers in the Asia-Pacific region. Objective This study aims to investigate (1) the psychological outcome characteristics of nurses in different Asia-Pacific countries and (2) psychological differences between nurses, doctors, and nonmedical health care workers. Methods Exploratory data analysis and visualization were conducted on the data collected through surveys. A machine learning modeling approach was adopted to further discern the key psychological characteristics differentiating nurses from other health care workers. Decision tree–based machine learning models (Light Gradient Boosting Machine, GradientBoost, and RandomForest) were built to predict whether a set of psychological distress characteristics (ie, depression, anxiety, stress, intrusion, avoidance, and hyperarousal) belong to a nurse. Shapley Additive Explanation (SHAP) values were extracted to identify the prominent characteristics of each of these models. The common prominent characteristic among these models is akin to the most distinctive psychological characteristic that differentiates nurses from other health care workers. Results Nurses had relatively higher percentages of having normal or unchanged psychological distress symptoms relative to other health care workers (n=233-260 [86.0%-95.9%] vs n=187-199 [74.8%-91.7%]). Among those without psychological symptoms, nurses constituted a higher proportion than doctors and nonmedical health care workers (n=194 [40.2%], n=142 [29.5%], and n=146 [30.3%], respectively). Nurses in Vietnam showed the highest level of depression, stress, intrusion, avoidance, and hyperarousal symptoms compared to those in Singapore, Malaysia, and Indonesia. Nurses in Singapore had the highest level of anxiety. In addition, nurses had the lowest level of stress, which is the most distinctive psychological outcome characteristic derived from machine learning models, compared to other health care workers. Data for India were excluded from the analysis due to the differing psychological response pattern observed in nurses in India. A large number of female nurses emigrating from South India could not have psychologically coped well without the support from family members while living alone in other states. Conclusions Nurses were least psychologically affected compared to doctors and other health care workers. Different contexts, cultures, and points in the pandemic curve may have contributed to differing patterns of psychological outcomes amongst nurses in various Asia-Pacific countries. It is important that all health care workers practice self-care and render peer support to bolster psychological resilience for effective coping. In addition, this study also demonstrated the potential use of decision tree–based machine learning models and SHAP value plots in identifying contributing factors of sophisticated problems in the health care industry.

Level of depression and its associated factors among the frontline physicians of Bangladesh during the COVID-19 outbreak

“…Other studies pointed out challenges like long working hours, lack of personal protective equipment, dealing with the escalating mortality of the patients and working in a confined and panic-ridden hospital environment while being isolated from their families for a long period of time acted as some key stressors for the healthcare professionals which affected their mental health to a great extent. [20][21][22][23][24][25][26] Evidence from various studies also revealed that compared to the general public, healthcare workers have been seen to be more negatively affected psychologically during this pandemic. 27 A Turkish study reported that healthcare professionals were more adversely affected by the pandemic compared to others in the country.…”

The challenge of community mental health interventions with patients, relatives, and health professionals during the COVID-19 pandemic: a real-world 9-month follow-up study

“…In our study we implemented different types of therapy, but it is studied 57 that the cognitive behaviour therapy is the most evidence-based treatment, included insomnia 58 , despite its high cost 59 . Fear of contagion of COVID-19, health training, and degree of exposure to the disease appear to be risk factors for suffering from psychological adversity 28,31,34,35 .…”

“…In the same way, the previous presence of physical symptoms 33 , previous medical problems and training in medicine and in self-control and protection measures 34 are identified as independent predictors of psychological adversity.…”

Association between COVID-19-related stress and self-directed learning ability among Korean nursing students

“…( Le et al, 2021 ). Dong et al (2022) observed that nurses reported relatively fewer psychological effects of COVID-19 than other healthcare workers. Chew, Ngiam et al (2020) examined the predictors (physical symptoms, prior medical conditions, and non-medically trained personnel) of mental health in healthcare workers.…”