Intraoperative control by Schanz‐screws is inaccurate to achieve the exact amount of correction in de‐rotational osteotomies

Abstract

Purpose The accuracy of intraoperative control of correction commonly is achieved by K‐wires or Schanz‐screws in combination with goniometer in de‐rotational osteotomies. The purpose of this study is to investigate the accuracy of intraoperative torsional control in de‐rotational femoral and tibial osteotomies. It is hypothesized, that intraoperative control by Schanz‐screws and goniometer in de‐rotational osteotomies around the knee is a safe and well predictable method to control the surgical torsional correction intraoperatively. Methods 55 consecutive osteotomies around the knee joint were registered, 28 femoral and 27 tibial. The indication for osteotomy was femoral or tibial torsional deformity with the clinical occurrence of patellofemoral maltracking or PFI. Pre‐ and postoperative torsions were measured according to the method of Waidelich on computed tomography (CT) scan. The scheduled value of torsional correction was defined by the surgeon preoperatively. Intraoperative control of torsional correction was achieved by 5 mm‐Schanz‐screws and goniometer. The measured values of torsional CT scan were compared to the preoperative defined and intended values and deviation was calculated separately for femoral and tibial osteotomies. Results The surgeon’s intraoperative measured mean value of correction in all osteotomies was 15.2° (SD 4.6; range 10–27), whereas the postoperatively measured mean value on CT scan was 15.6 (6.8; 5.0–28.5). Intraoperatively the femoral mean value measured 17.9° (4.9; 10–27) and 12.4° (1.9; 10–15) for the tibia. Postoperatively the mean value for femoral correction was 19.8 (5.5; 9.0–28.5) and 11.3 (5.0; 5.0–26.0) for tibial correction. When considering a deviation of plus or minus 3° to be acceptable femorally 15 osteotomies (53.6%) and tibially 14 osteotomies (51.9%) fell within these limits. Nine femoral cases (32.1.%) were overcorrected, four cases undercorrected (14.3%). Four tibial cases of overcorrection (14.8%) and 9 tibial cases of undercorrection (33.3%) were observed. However, the observed difference between femur and tibia regarding the distribution of cases between the three groups did not reach significance. Moreover, there was no correlation between the extent of correction and the deviation from the intended result. Conclusion The use of Schanz‐screws and goniometer in de‐rotational osteotomies as an intraoperative control of correction is an inaccurate method. Every surgeon performing derotational osteotomies must consider this and include postoperative torsional measurement in his postoperative algorithm until new tools or devices are available to guarantee a better intraoperative accuracy of torsional correction. Study design Observational study. Level of evidence III.