A (pybox)Ni catalyst (where pybox = pyridine−bis-(oxazoline)) promotes the reductive cyclization of β-hydroxy 1,1dichloroalkenes to form 2,3-dihydrofurans. The substrates for this reaction are conveniently prepared by an aldol addition, followed by one-carbon homologation. Chiral substrates are accessible in highly enantioenriched form, allowing for the synthesis of stereochemically complex 2,3,4trisubstituted products. Mechanistic studies support a vinylidene O−H insertion rather than a C−O cross-coupling pathway.