The Pummerer reaction proceeds from sulfoxide to a product via a sulfonium ion (II) which reacts with a nucleophile at the carbon (alkylation). 1) In the interrupted Pummerer reaction,2) an acylated sulfoxide intermediate (I) undergoes reaction with the nucleophile at the sulfur (sulfenylation), leading to unexpected products under Pummerer reaction conditions.The finding that the sulfonium ions may serve as electrophiles in electrophilic substitution has generally extended to the synthetic range of the Pummerer reaction.1) Thus, both intra-3) and intermolecular 4) versions of the process have been used to prepare a wide range of compounds. Recently, Padwa et al. emphasized in their review 5) that a-acyl sulfonium ions generated from a-acyl sulfoxides are highly reactive and can trap various nucleophiles involving carbon pbonds. In particular, they describe that the aromatic cyclization reactions in which an aromatic nuclei acts as the carbon nucleophile are useful to construct various complex polycyclic ring systems. More recently, we have demonstrated that simple alkyl sulfonium ions not having an a-acyl function are also able to induce aromatic cyclization under mild reaction conditions. 6) This approach provides a highly effective and convenient technique for preparing a variety of aromatic condensed N-heterocyles.
6,7)During the course of the investigations, we observed that alkyl sulfoxides, if the aromatic nucleophile is highly electron-rich, predominantly undergo intramolecular sulfenylation (interrupted Pummerer reaction), while if the aromatic nucleophile is not highly electron-rich, the sulfoxides undergo intramolecular alkylation (Pummerer reaction) in an exclusive manner.7b, g) Before our findings, Bates et al. had reported that a sulfoxide possessing a highly electron rich pyrrole as the nucleophile exclusively underwent intramolecular sulfenylation, when the side chain of an alkyl aryl sulfoxide was a simple alkyl, 2,8) while the reaction of a sulfoxide whose alkyl side chain contained an electron-withdrawing group on the a-carbon, induced aromatic intramolecular alkylation in an exclusive manner.9) These facts suggest that the reaction path can be diverted in one direction or the other by the proper choice of either a sulfoxide side chain or nucleophilic aromatic moiety.In this paper we treat the Pummerer reactions of two different types of sulfoxides, a simple alkyl sulfoxide (A) and an a-acyl sulfoxide (B) carrying two identical aromatic nucleophiles, with the expectation that the reactions should disclose what chemical properties of the sulfoxide side chains can control two different cyclization reactions. At the same time, the sulfoxides, because of having two aromatic nuclei of similar nucleophilicity, could conceivably cause two additional cyclizations, as shown in Chart 2: 1) Aromatic sulfenylation to benzothiazine, 2) aromatic sulfenylation to benzothiazepine, 3) aromatic alkylation to indole, and 4) aromatic alkylation to isoquinoline. Thus, this investigation may reveal the preference ...