Interventions to strengthen the leadership capabilities of health professionals in Sub-Saharan Africa: a scoping review

Abstract

Leadership is a critical component of a health system and may be particularly important in Sub-Saharan Africa, where clinicians take on significant management responsibilities. However, there has been little investment in strengthening leadership in this context, and evidence is limited on what leadership capabilities are most important or how effective different leadership development models are. This scoping review design used Arksey and O’Malley’s approach of identifying the question and relevant studies, selection, charting of data, summarizing of results and consultation. A comprehensive search strategy was used that included published and unpublished primary studies and reviews. Seven databases were searched, and papers written in English and French between 1979 and 2019 were included. Potential sources were screened against inclusion and exclusion criteria. Data were grouped into common categories and summarized in tables; categories included conceptual approach to leadership; design of intervention; evaluation method; evidence of effectiveness; and implementation lessons. The findings were then analysed in the context of the review question and objectives. Twenty-eight studies were included in the review out of a total of 495 that were initially identified. The studies covered 23 of the 46 countries in Sub-Saharan Africa. The leadership development programmes (LDPs) described were diverse in their design. No consistency was found in the conceptual approaches they adopted. The evaluation methods were also heterogeneous and often of poor quality. The review showed how rapidly leadership has emerged as a topic of interest in health care in Sub-Saharan Africa. Further research on this subject is needed, in particular in strengthening the conceptual and competency frameworks for leadership in this context, which would also inform better evaluation. Our findings support the need for LDPs to be accredited, better integrated into existing systems and to put greater emphasis on institutionalization and financial sustainability from their early development.

A mid-level health manager intervention to promote uptake of isoniazid preventive therapy among people with HIV in Uganda: a cluster randomised trial

“…Health system supervisors are often clinicians with little or no formal leadership or management training. 29 Several studies have found associations between leadership and management skills of health system supervisors and health outcomes, including childhood vaccination and primary care delivery. 30 , 31 The leadership and management training we provided might have contributed to intervention effectiveness by improving competence in these areas and offering concrete tools to apply these skills.…”

Health System Determinants of Hypertension Care and Outcomes in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Systematic Review

“…While leadership and governance are central to the success of any endeavor to improve the quality of care, their role and impact in advancing hypertension care in SSA are not widely researched, and the few existing studies are predominantly of poor quality [96]. Thornton highlighted the critical values of leadership commitment, willingness to fund care, strategic and creative local and foreign partnerships, and evidence-based guidelines as the key reasons why Botswana surpassed the United Nations’ HIV management goals of 95% awareness, 95% on treatment, and 95% [81].…”

Building leadership and managerial capacity for maternal and newborn health services

“…While much of the emphasis was on building leadership capacity, the project included management capacity as there was an observed need for improvement in this area as well. In a scoping review of leadership programs in Sub-Saharan Africa, Johnson and colleagues [ 36 ] found that many of the programs combined leadership and management capacity building, which they concluded was reasonable, given than the leaders within the health facilities are also, in many instances, managers who must oversee both change and performance.…”