Interventions targeting sexual and reproductive health and rights outcomes of young people living with HIV: a comprehensive review of current interventions from sub-Saharan Africa

Abstract

BackgroundA growing number of young people (ages 10–24) are living with HIV (YPLWH) in sub-Saharan Africa (SSA). These YPLWH have particular needs and challenges related to their sexual and reproductive health and rights (SRHR). Contextual factors including gender inequalities, violence, stigma, and discrimination and lack of tailored services undermine YPLWH's SRHR.ObjectiveUnderstand the scope and impact of interventions targeting YPLWH to improve SRH-related outcomes in SSA.DesignWe undertook a review to synthesise evaluated interventions (qualitative, quantitative, or mixed methods) aimed at improving the SRH outcomes of YPLWH in SSA with outcomes based on a World Health Organization framework of comprehensive SRHR approaches for women living with HIV. Using inclusion criteria, only six interventions were identified.ResultsInterventions sought to improve a range of direct and indirect SRH outcomes, including sexual behaviour, adherence, disclosure, and mental health. Four overarching issues emerged: 1) all interventions were structured according to cognitive behavioural therapy theories of behaviour change – while showing promise they do not tackle the wider gender, social, and economic contexts that shape YPLWH's SRH; 2) ‘significant others’ were included in two of the interventions, but further work needs to consider how to leverage parental/guardian support appropriately; 3) interventions only accessed young people who were already linked to care, participants were likely to have better SRH outcomes than those potentially more vulnerable YPLWH; and 4) none of the interventions explored the sexuality of young people.ConclusionsThere have been a limited number of evaluated interventions to strengthen SRH of YPLWH in SSA, and gaps exist in addressing the SRHR needs of YPLWH. Intervention approaches require greater scope and depth, including the need to address structural and contextual challenges.

Tuberculosis stigma as a social determinant of health: a systematic mapping review of research in low incidence countries

“…Lessons may be learned from the HIV field, where socio-ecological models have been applied routinely to interventions to tackle the multiple drivers of stigma in people with HIV. 42,76,77 Attention and action on HIV stigma have also stemmed from the creation of a distinct, indeed exceptional, HIV community as a result of the more acute levels of discrimination experienced by those affected in the early stages of the global epidemic. The very forces that suppressed the rights of people with HIV led to mass movements of global resistance, world over, to quell systematic actions on the parts of individuals, systems, and governments, that could compound their stigmatization.…”

A Global Research Agenda for Adolescents Living With HIV

“… 9 , 41 In addition, ALHIV SRH needs are not being met because specific services and information are insufficient and often inaccessible. 42 , 43 Despite the increased awareness of the requirements for support, few studies have tested and compared different interventions. New and optimized strategies to address ALHIV psychosocial support, mental health, and SRH needs are urgently needed both at individual and program level.…”

What is it going to take to move youth‐related HIV programme policies into practice in Africa?

“…At a community and social level, evidence suggests [37] that adolescents and young people living with HIV face additional and more complex challenges as they explore their sexual identity, form relationships and face disclosure to partners and peers. Qualitative studies identify stigma as a central barrier for adolescents as they struggle to maintain treatment, and particular challenges in managing adherence and contraception within shifting and often fraught teenage romantic relationships [38].…”