“…This is in disagreement with Gottwald et al who instead report on three broad structures at 72.2, 74.9, and 76.2 eV, that is, in a region where we do not detect any photoelectron signal within our error bars. The expected energy positions of the Xe 2+ 4d −1 5p −1 states which are populated upon 4d shell ionization of Xe + (5p −1 ) states can be deduced from the literature, namely, from the measurement by Kivimäki et al [25] of the "4p" photoelectron spectrum of the Xe atom and of the associated "N 3 " N 4,5 O 2,3 Coster-Kronig decay to these Xe 2+ 4d −1 5p −1 states. They are summarized in Table I using the binding-energy scale relative to the ground state of the Xe atom.…”