Internet Galaxy Meets Postnational Constellation: Prospects for Political Solidarity After the Internet

Abstract

Might online social relations play a role in the rise of political solidarities sufficient to support a democratic postnationalist project? As things currently stand, it does not appear that the Internet supports either the commitment or cohesiveness needed to underpin a demanding new mode of social and political relations. Looking at factors such as conceptions of community and social interaction, systems of meaning, political engagement, and social inclusivity can help us assess the question. The exercise suggests that while the Internet may be a factor in change, it may not yield the kind of change many are anticipating. This finding raises doubts concerning the postnationalist hope that new social and political bonds will help ground transnational projects such as the European Union.

Care and Solidarity Are Conditions for Interventionist Research

“…STS scholars have written about the role of solidarity in intellectual movements (Amsterdamska 1987) and in theories of scientific change via mechanisms of "mutual dependence" (Fuchs 1993). We've developed different models for dispersed solidarity such as "cosmopolitanized risk collectivities" (Beck and Levy 2013) and "networked solidarity" (Frost 2006). Solidarity is even central to Donna Haraway's definition of feminist science (Haraway 2004, 69.…”

From Culture to Connection: Internet Community Studies

“…Without one, it is difficult to develop the other, because there is no reference point for differentiation or affiliation. Temporary identities ... provide a poor basis for solidarity building’ (Frost 2006: 46–7, see also Friedman and Resnick 2001). The low degree of investment in an easily assumed and easily discarded online persona makes it easier for individuals move rapidly between groups and to form ever more homogenous communities.…”

Internet-Mediated Experiences of Underdevelopment: A Four-Country Survey of Academia

“…In the past decade or more, nonetheless, of expanding "knowledge economies", academic assessments as well as popular accounts of the development of information technology and the Internet in particular, have been far more measured (e.g. Castells 1996Castells , 1998Frost 2006;Slevin 2000;Stoll 1995). 2 We have become aware of various and complex "digital divides" (e.g.…”