Intergroup Competition as a Double-Edged Sword: How Sex Composition Regulates the Effects of Competition on Group Creativity

Abstract

Building on social role theory, we extend a contingency perspective on intergroup competition proposing that having groups compete against one another is stimulating to the creativity of groups composed largely or exclusively of men but detrimental to the creativity of groups composed largely or exclusively of women. We tested this idea in two separate studies: a laboratory experiment (Study 1) and a field study (Study 2). Study 1 showed that competition had the expected positive effects on the creativity of groups composed mostly or exclusively of men and produced the predicted negative effects on the creativity of groups composed of women, even though the latter effects emerged at the high end of the competition spectrum and for sex-homogeneous groups only. Results of Study 1 also revealed that within-group collaboration mediated the joint effects of competition and sex composition on group creativity. Study 2 replicated the results of Study 1 in a field setting involving research and development teams. We discuss the implications of these findings for theory and practice.

Gender Diversity, R&D Teams and Patents: An Application to Spanish Firms

“…From a theoretical perspective, gender diversity increases creativity and innovation, as it leads to a greater diversity in terms of skills and abilities (Lazear, 1999;Baer et al, 2013). This argument is in line with Cumming and Oldham (1997), and with Bharadwaj and Menon (2000), who point out that team creativity is crucial for innovation at company level.…”

Competitive Science: Is Competition Ruining Science?

“…Experimental studies of groups of undergraduates and scientists in the real world have revealed important differences between how men and women tend to respond to competition. In one such study, intense competition between teams enhanced creativity in teams composed of men but impeded creativity in teams composed of women, whereas women thrived in a collaborative environment in which teams worked side by side (54). This might relate to deep-seated gender differences in cooperation and competition that have been designated the "male-warrior hypothesis" (55).…”

Walking Parallel Paths or Taking the Same Road? The Effect of Collaborative Incentives in Innovation Contests

“…Baer et al (2013) find a positive effect of competition on creativity. Another aspect influenced by competition is that more "experimentation" and "creative destruction" take place.…”