Intergenerational transmission of parenting: findings from a UK longitudinal study

Abstract

Background: The quality of parenting is associated with a wide range of child and adult outcomes, and there is evidence to suggest that some aspects of parenting show patterns of intergenerational transmission. This study aimed to determine whether such intergenerational transmission occurs in mothers and fathers in a UK birth cohort. Methods: The study sample consisted of 146 mothers and 146 fathers who were recruited from maternity wards in England and followed up for 24 months [‘Generation 2’ (G2)]. Perceptions of their own parenting [by ‘Generation1’ (G1)] were assessed from G2 parents at 12 months using the Parental Bonding Instrument (PBI). G2 parents were filmed interacting with their ‘Generation 3’ (G3) children at 24 months. Results: We found that G1 mothers’ ‘affection’ was associated with positive parenting behaviour in the G2 fathers (‘positive responsiveness’ β = 0.19, P = 0.04 and ‘cognitive stimulation’ β = 0.26, P < 0.01). G1 mothers’ ‘control’ was associated with negative parenting behaviour in G2 mothers (decreased ‘engagement’ β = −0.19, P = 0.04), and negative parenting behaviour in G2 fathers (increased ‘control’ β = 0.18, P = 0.05). None of the G1 fathers’ parenting variables were significantly associated with G2 parenting. Conclusions: There is evidence of intergenerational transmission of parenting behaviour in this highly educated UK cohort, with reported parenting of grandmothers associated with observed parenting in both mothers and fathers. No association was seen with reported parenting of grandfathers. This raises the possibility that parenting interventions may have benefits that are realised across generations.

Transgenerational Patterns of Communication Orientations and Depression Among Mothers and Adult Children

“…Moreover, specific positive parenting behaviors such as warmth, responsiveness, and encouragement have transgenerational tendencies (Schofield, Conger, & Neppl, 2014). In a longitudinal study, Madden et al (2015) reported that parenting behaviors such as parental control, responsiveness, and decreased engagement transmitted across generations. Clearly, children learn how to communicate as a parent based, in part, on observing their parent's behaviors.…”

Association of teen mothers’ and grandmothers’ parenting capacities with child development: A study protocol

“…This may help explain why the teen's mother is often identified as an important source of support for teen mothers and their children (Beers & Hollo, ; Hudson et al, ; Spieker & Bensley, ). Evidence continues to emerge of intergenerational transmission of parenting behaviors and quality; most compelling is the influence of grandmothers (Kretchmar & Jacobvitz, ; Madden et al, ). Greater social support and more positive grandmother relationships have been associated with greater parenting competence and higher levels of nurturing behaviors among teen mothers (Oberlander, Black, & Starr, ; Sellers, Black, Boris, Oberlander, & Myers, ).…”

Ideación suicida en adolescentes del área rural: estilo de crianza y bienestar psicológico

“…Al respecto, un estudio transversal aplicado en niños de Rumania puntualiza que el nivel educativo y la historia personal de los padres influyen en el tipo de relaciones que estos establecen con sus hijos (69), mientras que otro estudio longitudinal sugiere patrones de transmisión intergeneracional, ya que de acuerdo con la evaluación la paternidad positiva o negativa era transmitida por las conductas de paternidad de las abuelas (70). En otro estudio, donde se examinó una muestra de participantes de los suburbios de alto riesgo en Seattle, con edades entre 10 y 27 años, se estableció que existe relación entre la actual crianza autoritaria e inflexible percibida por los encuestados y los comportamientos antisociales desarrollados por los padres desde su infancia-adolescencia hasta la vida adulta (71).…”