Intensification of Upland Agriculture in Thailand: Development or Degradation?

Abstract

The large scale conversion of extensive swidden agriculture to intensive market oriented production of maize in upland areas of South East Asia is a cause of environmental concern. This study investigates how intensive maize cultivation affects soil quality in an upland area of Northern Thailand by comparing commonly used indicators of soil quality in soils from maize fields used at various intensities. Relations between these indicators and concentration of permanganate oxidizable carbon (Pox‐C) – a low cost proxy for soil quality – are also examined. The extent, type and drivers of land use changes between 2002 and 2012 are investigated by classification of high resolution satellite images, interviews, participatory mapping and questionnaires. We document a widespread change from traditional swidden agriculture to intensive cultivation of maize that is mainly brought about by economcic and political drivers. We show that the concentration of Pox‐C in the top soil of the maize fields is closely related to common indicators of soil quality and to farmers' perceptions of soil quality. Most of the other soil quality indicators are negatively – albeit not significantly – related to intensity of maize cultivation. There is a strong negative correlation between intensity of maize cultivation and concentration of Pox‐C in the upper 5 cm of the soil where the Pox‐C concentration declines with a rate of 40 mg year under maize−1. We conclude that Pox‐C is a sensitive indicator of effects of land use intensity on the soil and a useful integrative measure of soil quality. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Documentation of farmer perceptions and site‐specific properties to improve soil management on smallholder farms in Tanzania

“…Previous studies assessing farmer perceptions of soil fertility in East Africa were unable to find differences between soil fertility status groups (Berazneva et al, ; Kelly & Anderson, ). In an in‐depth study in Southeast Asia focused on a smaller geographical area, Bruun et al () compared multiple soil quality measurements to farmer perceptions of soil fertility status and found pH and active carbon to have the greatest differences between groups, whereas SOC did not differ. In large household surveys such as the World Bank Living Standards Measurement Study (LSMS), soil fertility is documented based on questions about current status but we know no large‐scale surveys that consider farmer perceptions of trends in soil fertility status over time.…”

Simulating Stakeholder-Based Land-Use Change Scenarios and Their Implication on Above-Ground Carbon and Environmental Management in Northern Thailand

“…Nevertheless, there can be large variations in carbon sequestration potentials depending on tree species planted, management practices and local environmental conditions [4]. The reported minimum and average above-ground carbon stock data that were used in the carbon-stock accounting procedure were comparable to other studies in South-East Asia [3,4]. However, the maximum time-averaged above-ground carbon stock data computed with the coupled modelling procedure in 2029 were in parts higher than other estimates for tropical environments [51,52] as a result of overall wide range of values reported in literature.…”

Barriers to Agro-Ecological Intensification of Smallholder Upland Farming Systems in Lao PDR

“…Improve soil fertility (16) Food (11) Weed control (5) Erosion control (3) Animal feed (1) Improve soil fertility (20) Food (15) Weed control (4) Erosion control (3) Animal feed (2) Constraints Drought (20) Grazing livestock (18) Grazing livestock (26) Drought (24) Facilitating factors…”

“…Shifting cultivation has been the dominant land-use system in the tropics for centuries [1]. However, over the last few decades, a gradual transformation away from shifting cultivation to permanent agriculture has been taking place in the uplands of Southeast Asia as a result of increasing population pressure, government policies and an expanding market infrastructure [2,3]. Laos is one of the countries experiencing such a transformation, with fodder maize (Zea mays L.) being one of the commodity crops grown in permanent agricultural systems or intensive shifting cultivation rotations [4,5].…”