Integrative negotiation model to support water resources management

Medeiros, Daysan F.K. Leal; Urtiga, Marcella Maia; Morais, Danielle Costa

doi:10.1016/j.jclepro.2017.02.160

Cited by 20 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 37 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Unclassified

Order By: Relevance

“…However, transboundary river water allocation involves heterogeneous water demand, with different goals and interests for riparian countries under different socialecono-environmental conditions (Yazdi and Moridi 2017). Forming satisfactory and mutually agreed upon agreements allocating limited water resources to multiple stakeholders with multiple optimization goals, riparian countries must use multi-stage negotiation (Yuan et al, 2016;Medeiros et al, 2017).…”

Section: Open Access Edited Bymentioning

confidence: 99%

Two-stage water resources allocation negotiation model for transboundary rivers under scarcity

Yuan

et al. 2022

Front. Environ. Sci.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

In this article, the bankruptcy theory and bargaining games are used to construct a two-stage water resources allocation negotiation model (TSANM). A Nash-bargaining game model is used for the initial allocation, followed by an adjustment stage which considers factors such as water circumstances, water satisfaction, water risk, and water efficiency. The TSANM systematically considers the multi-dimensional attributes of water resources in the allocation process and may likely increase the participation of riparian countries. The proposed method is applied to allocate the contested water capital of the Tigris-Euphrates River. This gives initial allocation to Turkey, Syria, and Iraq of 30.00%, 22.00%, and 48.00%, respectively, and adjusted allocation of 24.98%, 21.30%, and 53.72%. Through collective bargaining and group negotiation, the stability and acceptability of allocation are effectively improved, absolute egalitarianism and utilitarianism are both avoided, and instead objectivity and fairness are emphasized in the water resources allocation process.

show abstract

Section: Open Access Edited Bymentioning

confidence: 99%

Two-stage water resources allocation negotiation model for transboundary rivers under scarcity

Yuan

et al. 2022

Front. Environ. Sci.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…Even though the presented methods above are efficient and effective for handling single-objective water allocation systems, they remain invalid for handling the coupling relationship between the tax rate and target revenue for the entire basin and provinces/regions in the river basin, which is a problem requiring equilibrium solutions for multi-objective optimal allocation (Bagatin et al 2014). In addition, previous water allocation and dispatching schemes are not based on solving the sustainability among compromise resources consumption, economic development and environmental protection of the basin, and a real-time adjustment mechanism of error correction between the predicted runoff and actual runoff is not taken into account (Medeiros et al 2017).…”

Section: Research Gapmentioning

confidence: 99%

Sustainable Management and Environmental Protection for Basin Water Allocation: Differential Game-based Multiobjective Programming

Shi

et al. 2022

Water Resour Manage

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

It is important to manage water resources under emergy theory and its implementation mechanism for water dispatching considering both economic development and environmental needs. To balance compromise resources consumption, economic development and environment protection, a multi-objective dynamic differential game is proposed in this study to determine the optimal tax rate (OTR), optimal trading quantity of water (OTQW) in each province, and the optimal bargain price (OBP). Considering the sustainability of ecological environment, the quantification of negative sewage value and net carbon emission constraints are introduced into the water allocation. To maximize the target revenue functions, minimize the net carbon emission constraints and obtain the sustainable equilibrium solutions in the triple-level game, the costate function, Hamiltonian, and Lagrangian multiplier method are introduced.Then, a water dispatching structure is constructed for error correction between the predicted and actual runoff of the YRB. Taking Yellow River Basin as an example, the validity of the proposed framework and solution method were verified under different hydrological years, 6.5%~9.1% economic benefits higher than other schemes and 4.3%~5.9% net carbon emission lower than other schemes. Compared to previous studies, the standard deviation of economic value, social value, negative ecological environment value in this paper are the least, which indicates that this scheme can better meet the requirements of sustainable 2 development and environmental protection.

show abstract

“…Estudos têm apontado que as diferença nas interações entre os grupos de partes interessadas dificultam a implementação de políticas hídricas, destacando maiores prejuízos de articulação entre os setores locais/municipais (BARBOSA; MUSHTAQ; ALAN, 2017). Isso ressalta a importância de propostas que visem facilitar não só deliberações, mas a comunicação geral entre os atores envolvidos, para que estes possam dialogar sobre suas próprias percepções e entender as diferentes percepções de outras partes interessadas de diferentes setores (MEDEIROS; URTIGA; MORAIS, 2017;AL-JAWAD et al, 2019). Na atual realidade do estudo de caso, notou-se uma maior fragilidade das prefeituras no que concerne o monitoramento do PHA Capibaribee a inter-relação com demais órgãos competentes por este acompanhamento na escala da bacia.…”

Section: Proposta De Articulação Intermunicipalunclassified

Proposta de articulação intermunicipal para monitoramento das ações previstas no Plano Hidroambiental da bacia do rio Capibaribe-PE

Moura¹,

Falcão²,

Montenegro³

2020

RNGC

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

A articulação entre municípios que integram a unidade de planejamento da bacia hidrográfica é de suma importância para uma gestão hídrica participativa e inclusiva. Em Pernambuco, o Plano Hidroambiental da bacia do rio Capibaribe é vanguardista no Estado, à medida que traça diagnósticos e delimita planos de investimentos para alcance da sua sustentabilidade, prevendo a participação de múltiplos atores, entre os quais encontram-se as prefeituras. Nesse contexto, este artigo objetivou desenhar uma proposta de articulação intermunicipal para otimizar o monitoramento das ações previstas no Plano Hidroambiental do Capibaribe. Para tal, foram utilizados os métodos de análise documental e observação participante, possibilitando ainda a identificação do Eixo que demanda maior atuação das prefeituras, o qual foi utilizado como base para concepção da proposta. Os resultados mostraram que a ausência de articulação contribui para um monitoramento menos eficaz, que pode ser aperfeiçoado por meio de um sistema integrador que permita também a troca de experiências entre os gestores no âmbito da bacia. PALAVRAS-CHAVE: Gestão hídrica. Plano Hidroambiental. Articulação municipal.

show abstract

Integrative negotiation model to support water resources management

Cited by 20 publications

References 37 publications

Two-stage water resources allocation negotiation model for transboundary rivers under scarcity

Two-stage water resources allocation negotiation model for transboundary rivers under scarcity

Sustainable Management and Environmental Protection for Basin Water Allocation: Differential Game-based Multiobjective Programming

Proposta de articulação intermunicipal para monitoramento das ações previstas no Plano Hidroambiental da bacia do rio Capibaribe-PE

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About