Integration Through Inclusion? Probing the Effect of Government Presence on Voting Behavior in the Swiss Cantons, 1848–2022

Abstract

Switzerland is widely known for its successful integration of linguistic and religious minorities. At the same time, a prolonged absence from the collegial, seven-member central government can give rise to feelings of political exclusion. This begs the question whether inclusion really has the desired, let any alone any effect on political behavior. This paper makes use of the frequent use of referendums in Switzerland to assess the extent to which citizens vote differently when somebody from their canton of residence sits in the central government. Studied are all the 670 nationwide referendums held between 1848 and February 2022. Analyzed are cantonal turnout, approval rates, likelihood to vote as the federal government recommends, and chances of being overruled by the state-wide majority. The three main findings are that 1) government inclusion is indeed significantly associated with some of the positive effects theorized, 2) on average, these effects are very small, but also that 3) there are some stark cross-cantonal differences, which are due mostly to national minority languages. In short, including minorities matters more than including majorities.

Lobbyierende Kantone

“…Darauf will Unterkapitel 6.5 aufbauen. In Weiterentwicklung von Mueller (2020Mueller ( , 2023 sind Medien als informelle Strategie jedoch nicht prinzipiell «allen Regionen offenstehend» (Mueller, 2020, 244). Vorliegend wird argumentiert, dass bestimmte Rahmenbedingungen gegeben sein müssen, damit medienvermittelte Interessenvertretung greifen kann.…”