Integration of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria: their impacts on corporate sustainability performance

Abstract

In a corporate sustainability context, scholars have been studying internal and external relations provided by Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) criteria, mostly from the organizational perspective. Therefore, the main objective of this paper is to map and analyze the literature on the impacts of integrating ESG criteria on corporate sustainability performance from different points of view. The methodology used followed the Preferred Report Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) guidelines, corroborated by a critical analysis. The results indicate that the integration of ESG criteria, observed from different perspectives, strengthens corporate sustainability performance. They also revealed narrowing gaps in the literature regarding methodological analysis. Most of the papers in the analyzed sample use company-level data and employ regression analysis in their analysis. The present study concludes that companies, regardless of nationality, follow the guidelines of ESG criteria integration and such procedure brings several benefits. It points to the lack of more confirmatory research approaches from a workers’ perspective, as the interest remains in the economic-environmental realm from the organizations’ point of view. The absence of such evidence points to a gap in the literature that suggests the need for new study initiatives.

Investigating the integration of ESG factors into financial markets and its influence on sustainable economic growth in emerging Asian economies

“…Previous studies have also explored the relationship between economic growth and ESG performance in both developed and developing economies (Ahmad et al, 2023;Aldowaish et al, 2023;de Souza Barbosa, 2023). Some studies have found a positive correlation between economic growth and ESG performance, while others have found a negative or insignificant relationship.…”

“…Consequently, companies with robust ESG performance are expected to have a higher market value due to their potential for improved financial performance and reduced risk. Furthermore, financial institutions that promote the advancement of ESG performance in Asia are likely to witness growth in their own operations, leading to increased market value.Previous studies have also explored the relationship between economic growth and ESG performance in both developed and developing economies(Ahmad et al, 2023; Aldowaish et al, 2023;de Souza Barbosa, 2023). Some studies have found a…”

The purpose of the company beyond its position in the market: The new agent of social development

“…People have directed their interest to social benefit, inclusion, and transparent management of sustainable development (De Souza Barbosa et al, 2023). Attributes that collide with the structure of many corporations, established to privilege profits, benefit shareholders, and seek for prominence in the market (O'mara, 2023).…”

Can corporate ESG performance improve audit efficiency?: Empirical evidence based on audit latency perspective

“…The revised ’Guidelines on the Content and Format of Information Disclosure for Companies Issuing Securities (Public Issue No. 2—Content and Format of Annual Report)’ were released in June 2021, incorporating additional requirements for disclosing a company’s environmental, social responsibility, and corporate governance practices [ 2 ]. Data from the China Association of Listed Companies indicates that over 1,700 listed companies, representing 34% of the total, have independently prepared and published ESG-related reports for 2022.…”