Integration between women’s and men’s football clubs: a comparison between Brazil, China and Italy

Abstract

Despite an increasing interest from media and fans, one of the challenges women's football currently faces is the lack of resources to sustain its growth at both grassroots and elite levels. To cope with this issue, National Associations (NAs) of various countries have recently formulated a policy demanding men's football clubs to integrate a women's team within their structure. Using the Multiple Streams Framework, this article examines the context, timing and conditions leading to the implementation of the policy of integration in three different countries: Brazil, China and Italy. The authors collected and analysed policy documents and media reports to identify factors influencing the policy formulation. Results indicate declining performances of senior women's national team, low participation rates, external pressures from supranational football institutions and increased societal need to reduce gender disparities contribute to influence NAs' engagement with policies for the development of women's football. While potentially helping women's football enhance its visibility and commercialisation, the policy of integration risks the women's game continuing to be seen as subaltern to its men's counterpart. Implications of the policy of integration for the long-term development of women's football and its possible future scenarios are discussed.

Association between evergrande FC's club debt and Chinese super league's profitability from 2014 to 2019

“…Instead, the efficiency of capital expenditures and return should be judged in terms of the actual resources available for productive use in human society. Between 2014 and 2019, monetary transfer from the real estate industry to CSL left a plethora of legacies for Chinese society, including women and youth football involvement (9,31), upgraded consumer sports consumption (32), and modern urbanization (20). The Chinese Communist Party's success is premised on placing the interests of the people-centered.…”

Money troubles and problems ahead? The financial health of professional women's football clubs in England

“…In 2018, when the WSL became fully professional, multiple high-profile professional men's clubs applied to the FA to field professional women's teams as part of club franchises, notably Manchester United FC and West Ham United FC. A policy that has also been adopted abroad (Valenti et al ., 2021), the strategic “umbrella” that a seemingly wealthy professional men's football club could provide to the women's team was seen favourably by the FA because of the access to pre-existing business functions (Dunn and Welford, 2015). Yet the integration between the men's clubs and women's sections is not consistent across the league with variation in club focus, growth strategies and budget allocations.…”