Integrating otolith and genetic tools to reveal intraspecific biodiversity in a highly impacted salmon population

Abstract

Intraspecific biodiversity is vital for species persistence in an increasingly volatile world. By embracing methods that integrate information at different spatiotemporal scales, we can directly monitor and reconstruct changes in intraspecific biodiversity. Here we combined genetics and otolith biochronologies to describe the genotypic and phenotypic diversity of Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in the Yuba River, California, comparing cohorts that experienced a range of hydroclimatic conditions. Yuba River salmon have been heavily impacted by habitat loss and degradation, and large influxes of unmarked hatchery fish each year have led to concern about introgression and uncertainty around the viability of its wild populations, particularly the rarer spring‐run salmon. Otolith strontium isotopes showed that Yuba River origin fish represented, on average, 42% (range 7%–73%) of spawners across six return years (2009–2011, 2018–2020), with large interannual variability. The remainder of adult Chinook salmon in the river were primarily strays from the nearby Feather River hatchery, and since 2018 from the Mokelumne River hatchery. Among the Yuba‐origin spawners, on average, 30% (range 14%–50%) exhibited the spring‐run genotype. The Yuba‐origin fish also displayed a variety of outmigration phenotypes that differed in the timing and size at which they left the Yuba river. Early‐migrating fry dominated the returns (mean 59%, range 33%–89%), and their contribution rates were negatively correlated with freshwater flows. It is unlikely that fry survival rates are elevated during droughts, suggesting that this trend reflects disproportionately low survival of larger later migrating parr, smolts, and yearlings along the migratory corridor in drier years. Otolith daily increments indicated generally faster growth rates in non‐natal habitats, emphasizing the importance of continuing upstream restoration efforts to improve in‐river growing conditions. Together, these findings show that, despite a long history of habitat degradation and hatchery introgression, the Yuba River maintains intraspecific biodiversity that should be taken into account in future management, restoration, and reintroduction plans. The finding that genotypic spring‐run are reproducing, surviving, and returning to the Yuba River every year suggests that re‐establishment of an independent population is possible, although hatchery‐wild interactions would need to be carefully considered. Integrating methods is critical to monitor changes in key genetic, physiological, and behavioral traits to assess population viability and resilience.

Remnant salmon life history diversity rediscovered in a highly compressed habitat

“…Additionally, the fact that we did not find more heterozygotes in this system also points to the maintenance of these distinct life histories and genotypes, despite homogenizing anthropogenic influences. Although we could not eliminate fish from the Feather Hatchery completely from our analysis as only 25% of fall-run fish in the CCV have their adipose fin clipped, isotopic evidence shows that Yuba origin spring and fall-run fish are returning to the river, as opposed to Feather River Hatcheryorigin fish (Willmes et al, 2024). This is encouraging, as it indicates that there is hope for an independent, genetically distinct Yuba River spring-run population.…”