Integrating human dimensions in decadal-scale prediction for marine social–ecological systems: lighting the grey zone

Abstract

The dynamics of marine systems at decadal scales are notoriously hard to predict—hence references to this timescale as the “grey zone” for ocean prediction. Nevertheless, decadal-scale prediction is a rapidly developing field with an increasing number of applications to help guide ocean stewardship and sustainable use of marine environments. Such predictions can provide industry and managers with information more suited to support planning and management over strategic timeframes, as compared to seasonal forecasts or long-term (century-scale) predictions. The most significant advances in capability for decadal-scale prediction over recent years have been for ocean physics and biogeochemistry, with some notable advances in ecological prediction skill. In this paper, we argue that the process of “lighting the grey zone” by providing improved predictions at decadal scales should also focus on including human dimensions in prediction systems to better meet the needs and priorities of end users. Our paper reviews information needs for decision-making at decadal scales and assesses current capabilities for meeting these needs. We identify key gaps in current capabilities, including the particular challenge of integrating human elements into decadal prediction systems. We then suggest approaches for overcoming these challenges and gaps, highlighting the important role of co-production of tools and scenarios, to build trust and ensure uptake with end users of decadal prediction systems. We also highlight opportunities for combining narratives and quantitative predictions to better incorporate the human dimension in future efforts to light the grey zone of decadal-scale prediction.

A risk assessment for the remote ocean: the case of the South East Atlantic

“…climate regulation, many cultural services). Such ecosystem services arise from countless relationships between assets, operating cumulatively and synchronously across all spatial and temporal scales (Thurber et al, 2014;Drazen et al, 2020;Tilot et al, 2021;Melbourne-Thomas et al, 2023). Accordingly, key attributes of ABNJ include its position as the 'connector' of coastal environments and water masses to enable global ocean processes (e.g.…”

Supporting places left to the sea: A place-based research agenda for regional coastal transformations in the blue economy

“…Environmental geographers and human geographers are well placed to utilise some of the broad theories that resonate across our transformative processes in some way, and thus could build on the early integration we offer. For example, theory related to socio-ecological systems (Melbourne-Thomas et al 2023), geographical political economy (Sheppard 2011), socio-technical transitions (Geels 2019), feminist geographies (Barra 2023), political ecology (Jessee 2022), and blue degrowth, are all theoretical frameworks used by geographers that could speak to the three transformative processes to some extent. For example, blue degrowth seeks an alternative and utopian imaginary for the use of, access to, and relations with the seas, oceans and their resources by society – thus emphasizing how socio-cultural change can ensure more sustainable physical-environmental uses of blue resources in techno-industrial activities (Kaşdoğan, 2020; Said and MacMillan 2019).…”

Improving the relevance of the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways for sustainability science

“…Expanding imaginaries of what could be possible in a sustainable future may be a more desirable outcome than quantifying every aspect of those possibilities (Eschrich & Miller, 2021;Stoddard et al, 2021;Strand, Saltelli, Giampietro, Rommetveit, & Funtowicz, 2018). Co-production can be one method for broadening the focus of scenarios (Melbourne-Thomas et al, 2022;Wyborn et al, 2020). Qualitative modelling such as envisioning (Bryan et al, 2013) or conceptual modelling methods (Easdale & López, 2016;Sedlacko, Martinuzzi, Røpke, Videira, & Antunes, 2014) can incorporate imaginaries and coproduction, and Moallemi et al, (2021) examined the range of qualitative and quantitative methods for developing pathways to sustainable futures.…”