Cell-based cartilage tissue engineering
faces a great challenge
in the repair process, partly due to the special physical microenvironment.
Human stem cell from apical papilla (hSCAP) shows great potential
as seed cells because of its versatile differentiation capacity. However,
whether hSCAP has potent chondrogenic differentiation ability in the
physical microenvironment of chondroid remains unknown. In this study,
we fabricated poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) substrates with different
stiffnesses and investigated the chondrogenic differentiation potential
of hSCAPs. First, we found that hSCAPs cultured on soft substrates
spread more narrowly accompanied by cortical actin organization, a
hallmark of differentiated chondrocytes. On the contrary, stiff substrates
were favorable for cell spreading and stress fiber formation. More
importantly, the increased chondrogenic differentiation of hSCAPs
seeded on soft substrates was confirmed by characterizing increased
extracellular proteoglycan aggregation through Alcian blue staining
and Safranin O staining and enhanced markers toward chondrogenic differentiation
including SRY-box transcription factor 9 (Sox9), type II collagen
(Col2), and aggrecan in both normal α-minimum essential medium
(αMEM) and specific chondrogenic medium (CM) culture conditions.
Then, we investigated the mechanosensing/mechanotransduction governing
the chondrogenic differentiation of hSCAPs in response to different
stiffnesses and found that stiffness-sensitive integrin β1 and
focal adhesion kinase (FAK) were essential for mechanical signal perception
and were oriented at the start of mechanotransduction induced by matrix
stiffness. We next showed that the increased nuclear accumulation
of Smad3 signaling and target Sox9 facilitated the chondrogenic differentiation
of hSCAPs on the soft substrates and further verified the importance
of Rho-associated protein kinase (ROCK) signaling in regulating chondrogenic
differentiation and its driving factors, Smad3 and Sox9. By using
SIS3, the specific inhibitor of p-Smad3, and miRNA targeting Rho-associated
protein kinase 1 (ROCK-1), we finally confirmed the importance of
ROCK/Smad3/Sox9 axis in the chondrogenic differentiation of hSCAPs
in response to substrate stiffness. These results help us to increase
the understanding of how microenvironmental stiffness directs chondrogenic
differentiation from the aspects of mechanosensing, mechanotransduction,
and cell fate decision, which will be of great value in the application
of hSCAPs in cartilage tissue engineering.