Inspiratory muscle training in patients with Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis: A systematic review

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis is a neurodegenerative disease with rapid involvement of the inspiratory muscles, leading to respiratory insufficiency. Death often occurs by aspiration and pneumonia. Endurance-and strength therapy within ALS are discussed controversially. OBJECTIVE: To review the current literature to assess the efficacy of inspiratory muscle training for ALS. METHOD: Systematic review, using databases as PubMed, PEDro, Cochrane and Google Scholar. INTERVENTION: Inspiratory muscle training vs. sham training or inspiratory muscle training alone. OUTCOME MEASURES: Inspiratory muscle strength, dyspnoea, quality of life and survival time. RESULTS: Four studies could be included in this review, two RCT´s, one pre-experimental study and one with a historical control group. In total 73 patients underwent inspiratory muscle training. CONCLUSION: Studies varied in onset of the training, the training protocol and the outcomes measured.At time, there is limited evidence that inspiratory muscle training leads to strengthening of inspiratory muscles in ALS. Improvements made were minor, in only a few parameters and also in control groups. Survival time was significantly longer in the experimental group in one study. Interesting suppositions (diaphragm training vs. other IM training, improvement of chest wall and lung compliance) need to be examined in robustly designed future trials, defining exact therapeutic windows and interventions.

Home mechanical ventilation for patients with Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis: A Canadian Thoracic Society clinical practice guideline

“…A systematic review 105 and a meta-analysis 106 have been published looking at the question of benefit of respiratory muscle training in ALS. The earlier systematic review 105 found no convincing evidence of benefit.…”

Supporting access to activities to enhance well‐being and reduce social isolation in people living with motor neurone disease

“…According to the Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Functional Rating Scale ALSFRSR (Cedarbaum et al., 1999), a score below 30 indicates a moderate presentation of the disease and was used to inform inclusion. Exercise is known to be contraindicated with chronic symptomatology (Eidenberger & Nowotny, 2014). Participants with a score above 30 were considered and judged on a case‐by‐case basis, this was because wheelchair users or those with swallowing or speech problems may have a score above 30, but could be capable of participation.…”

Physical activity and exercise interventions for people with rare neurological disorders: a scoping review of systematic reviews

“…Two systematic reviews included studies lasting from 12 weeks to 32 months and investigating respiratory training in individuals living with MND, including: respiratory training muscle and yoga breathing technique. In one study, duration per session was 10 minutes, while other studies reported 10 to 15 repetitions per sessions, two to five times a day, every day (29,59).…”