Insights Into Relationships Between Body Mass, Composition and Bone: Findings in Elite Rugby Players

Abstract

Recent reports indicate that bone strength is not proportional to body weight in obese populations.Elite rugby players have a similar body mass index (BMI) to obese individuals, but differ markedly with low body fat, high lean mass and frequent skeletal exposure to loading through weight-bearing exercise. The purpose of this study was to determine relationships between body weight, composition and bone strength in male rugby players characterised by high BMI and high lean mass.Fifty two elite male rugby players and 32 non-athletic, age-matched controls differing in BMI ; p=0.02) received one total body and one total hip DXA scan. Hip Structural Analysis of the proximal femur was used to determine bone mineral density (BMD) and cross-sectional bone geometry. Multiple linear regression was computed to identify independent variables associated with total hip and femoral neck BMD and HSA-derived bone geometry parameters. Analysis of covariance was used to explore differences between groups. Further comparisons between groups were performed after normalising parameters to body weight and to lean mass. There was a trend for a positive fat-bone relationship in rugby players, and a negative relationship in controls, although neither reached statistical significance. Correlations with lean mass were stronger for bone geometry (r 2 =0.408-0.520) than for BMD (r 2 =0.267-0.293).Relative to body weight, BMD was 6.7% lower in rugby players than controls (p<0.05). Rugby players were heavier than controls, with greater lean mass and BMD (p<0.01). Relative to lean mass, BMD was 10-14.3% lower in rugby players (p<0.001). All bone geometry measures except cross-sectional area, were proportional to body weight and lean mass. To conclude, BMD in elite rugby players was reduced in proportion to body weight and lean mass. However, their superior bone geometry suggests that overall bone strength may be adequate for loading demands. Fat-bone interactions in athletes engaged in high impact sports require further exploration.

Overfat and Underfat: New Terms and Definitions Long Overdue

“…In another study, nearly 50% of men and women classified as obese using densitometric methods were determined to be of normal BMI (33). Athletes who build high levels of muscle (lean body) mass often possess BMI levels above 30 and would be inappropriately classified as obese (34). However, when they retire, many will increase their body fat levels substantially, while maintaining their high BMI.…”

Interpretation of Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry-Derived Body Composition Change in Athletes: A Review and Recommendations for Best Practice

“…Of all fields, sports science and medicine has witnessed a considerable rise in the number of published research studies utilising DXA for the assessment of total and regional body composition. These studies have included the body composition profiling of competitive athletes [3,4], and in relation to bone density [5][6][7] and nutritional status [8,9]. Serial DXA measurements are increasingly being used to explore the effects of training and diet on athlete body composition changes [10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17].…”

Baseline Analysis of Patients Presenting for Surgical Review of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Rupture Reveals Heterogeneity in Patient-Reported Outcome Measures

“…The high proportion of patients classified as overweight-obese (68.8%) by the BMI method in the present study is a reflection of the sports commonly played by our patient population, in particularly rugby and Australian rules football where larger body frames are advantageous with high contact play. 21 Post-hoc analysis of the IKDC scores revealed that Cluster 4, the subgroup with the highest overall health and knee function scores, reported the ability to perform a higher level of activity without experiencing instability, at a higher than expected rate compared with Cluster 1. These findings highlight the need to clearly establish the reasons why patients decide to undergo ACL reconstruction.…”