“…Many possible types of active species or crucial structural factors have been advocated-from small metallic particles [106], to ultrasmall nonmetallic particles [107], to ultrasmall anionic clusters [63], to oxidized gold particles [108], to an ensemble of metallic Au atoms and a cationic Au [109] or cationic species [110,111], to a prominent role of the type of support material (i.e., ''active'' and ''inert'' supports) [53,112], presence of specific functional groups or effect of moisture [109,[113][114][115], importance of the particle-support perimeter region [116], and even effects of the specific catalytic testing conditions [117]. Moreover, the thermodynamic stability of adsorbed intermediates depends on the specific catalyst system and could either increase or decrease as a function of particle size below 8 nm [112]. Importantly, the presence of the elusive ultrasmall Au nanoparticles, undetectable by conventional particle X-ray diffraction (PXRD) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) techniques, in the case of catalysts made using popular supports (SiO 2 -TiO 2 ), has also been reported [118].…”