Mycobacteria diverge in a basic way from other bacterial and eukaryotic cells based on their distinct membrane structures. Here we report genome-wide transposon sequencing to discover the controllers of membrane compartmentalization in Mycobacterium smegmatis. cfa, a gene that encodes a putative cyclopropane-fatty-acyl-phospholipid synthase, shows the most significant effect on recovery from a membrane destabilizer, dibucaine. Lipidomic analysis of cfa deletion mutants demonstrates an essential role of Cfa in the synthesis of specific membrane lipids containing a C19:0 monomethyl-branched stearic acid. This molecule, also known as tuberculostearic acid (TBSA), has been intensively studied for decades due to its high level and genus-specific expression in mycobacteria. The proposed Cfa-mediated conversion of an unsaturation to a methylation matched well with its proposed role in lateral membrane organization, so we used new tools to determine the non-redundant effects of Cfa and TBSA in mycobacterial cells. cfa expression regulated major classes of membrane lipids including phosphatidylinositols, phosphatidylethanolamines and phosphatidylinositol mannosides. Cfa localized within the intracellular membrane domain (IMD), where it controls both cellular growth and recovery from membrane fluidization by facilitating subpolar localization of the IMD. Overall, cfa controls lateral membrane partitioning but does not detectably alter orthogonal transmembrane permeability. More generally, these results support the proposed role of the subpolar IMD as a subcellular site of mycobacterial control of membrane function.