Innovation in environmental assessment of community‐based projects in sub‐Saharan Africa

Abstract

Although environmental assessment (EA) has been applied to large resource and infrastructure projects in developing countries, recent innovations in EA concepts, processes and tools have facilitated its application to small projects focused on basic human and livelihood needs. This paper describes innovations in the application of EA to community projects implemented by Canadian nongovernment organizations and their partners in sub‐Saharan Africa. Innovations include: (1) the dovetailing of environmental constructs in neopopulism with a conceptual shift in EA toward participatory, transactive planning; (2) assessment methodologies adapted from participatory rural appraisal; (3) development of grassroots EA capacity; and (4) linkage of community EA with project planning. Community EA is demonstrated for five cases involving agriculture and charcoal retail in Uganda, water supply and flood control in Niger and integrated rural development in Zambia. Future prospects and challenges include cultural adaptation, community empowerment through realignment of power relationships, mutual development of local and national EA capacity and increased training and resources for enhancing grassroots EA capacity.

Taking a learning approach to community-based strategic environmental assessment: results from a Costa Rican case study

“…In particular, little research has been done on the learning component of CBSEA (Neefjes 2001;Spaling 2003;Spaling and Vroom 2007).…”

“…As such, this study considers transformative learning within a Latin American context at the cross-cultural nexus between industry and farmers. CBEAs have generally taken place in developing-world contexts, involving community, non-governmental organizations and statelevel stakeholders (Neefjes 2001;Spaling 2003;Spaling and Vroom 2007). Better understanding the relationship between the cultural context, learning process and social action can bring insight into the nuances of the communities involved, their interactions with outside actors, and the kinds of collective action and resourcemanagement outcomes that result from participation in community-based resource management activities (Agrawal and Gibson 1999); this is particularly important if trying to encourage sustainability-thinking in the face of uncertainty, complexity and conflict .…”

Sustaining water supply through a phased community management approach: lessons from Ghana’s “oats” water supply scheme

“…Traditional decision-making structures have some merits as argued by Spaling (2003). However, some aspects are at variance with contemporary requirements of democratic governance, women involvement in decision-making, transparency, and accountability.…”

Environmental assessment after the 2004 tsunami: a case study, lessons and prospects

“…These processes also are being adapted and tested for EA of international development projects (CIDA, 2005a;Pallen, 1996;Spaling et al, 2001). An EA that uses community-centered processes for assessing the environmental sustainability of small development projects is referred to as community EA (Spaling, 2003).…”