Informing as National Indifference? The Case of Finnish Citizens’ Collaboration with the Russian Authorities, 1899–1917

Abstract

Between 1899 and 1917, hundreds of Finnish citizens approached the Russian authorities with letters of denunciation, in which they reported about the anti-government activity of their fellow citizens. These informers caused a public stir in Finland because their activity was associated with the intensifying political surveillance of the imperial security police. Finnish nationalists eagerly labeled informers as Russian-minded traitors, but how did the informers themselves relate to the nation and the empire? This article tackles this question by analyzing the communication of these citizens with the Governor General's Office and the Gendarme Administration and by drawing inspiration from the concept of national indifference, which has gained prominence in nationalism studies in recent years. The article shows the great variation with which informers framed their ideological stance in their letters to the imperial power. Some avoided referring to their Finnishness to emphasize their imperial loyalty, whereas others presented themselves as pro-Finnish and viewed the interests of Finland and Russia as uniform. As a distinctive group of informers, the article examines Orthodox people, whose letters to the imperial authorities highlight experiences of religious discrimination and consequent national ambivalence.

National indifferences during everyday nationalism: Experiencing the nation in Finland in the aftermath of the Second World War

“…Historians have used the concept mainly within the context of late-19th and early-20th century Central and Eastern Europe, but the term has also been introduced to other periods and regions, including Finland (e.g. Jalagin, 2021;Suodenjoki, 2022;Verschaffel, 2019;Whittington, 2019). Depending on the context, national indifference has been associated, for example, with borderland populations possessing a marked local identity but with little linkage to nationalist projects, people shaping hybrid forms of regional and national identities or inhabitants in ethnically mixed regions pendulating between different national identifications (Miller, 2019;Zahra, 2010).…”