Information disclosure in clinical informed consent: “reasonable” patient’s perception of norm in high-context communication culture

Abstract

BackgroundThe current doctrine of informed consent for clinical care has been developed in cultures characterized by low-context communication and monitoring-style coping. There are scarce empirical data on patients’ norm perception of information disclosure in other cultures.MethodsWe surveyed 470 adults who were planning to undergo or had recently undergone a written informed consent-requiring procedure in a tertiary healthcare hospital in Saudi Arabia. Perceptions of norm and current practice were explored using a 5-point Likert scale (1 = strongly agree with disclosure) and 30 information items in 7 domains: practitioners’ details, benefits, risks, complications’ management, available alternatives, procedure’s description, and post-procedure’s issues.ResultsRespondents’ mean (SD) age was 38.4 (12.5); 50.2% were males, 57.2% had ≥ college education, and 37.9% had undergone a procedure. According to norm perception, strongly agree/agree responses ranged from 98.0% (major benefits) to 50.5% (assistant/trainee’s name). Overall, items related to benefits and post-procedure’s issues were ranked better (more agreeable) than items related to risks and available alternatives. Ranking scores were better in post-procedure respondents for 4 (13.3%) items (p < 0.001 to 0.001) and in males for 8 (26.7%) items (p = 0.008 to <0.001). Older age was associated with better ranking scores for 3 (10.0%) items and worse for one (p < 0.001 to 0.006). According to current practice perception, strongly agree/agree responses ranged from 93.3% (disclosure of procedure’s name) to 13.9% (lead practitioner’s training place), ranking scores were worse for all items compared to norm perception (p < 0.001), and post-procedure status, younger age, and lower educational level were associated with better ranking scores for 15 (50.0%), 12 (40.0%), and 4 (13.3%) items, respectively (p < 0.001 to 0.009).Conclusions1) even in an overall high-context communication culture, extensive and more information than is currently disclosed is perceived as norm, 2) the focus of the desired information is closer to benefits and post-procedure’s issues than risks and available alternatives, 3) male, post-procedure, and older patients are in favor of more information disclosure, 4) male, older, and more educated patients may be particularly dissatisfied with current information disclosure. The focus and extent of information disclosure for clinical informed consent may need to be adjusted if a “reasonable” patient’s standard is to be met.

Exploring end of life priorities in Saudi males: usefulness of Q-methodology

“…Arab countries, including Saudi Arabia have been characterized by high-context communication culture [ 44 ] and blunting coping style, [ 45 ] and it was hypothesized that in such cultures using “Western” reasonable patient standard of information disclosure may not be appropriate [ 46 ]. The results of this study and our previous study on desired information disclosure in clinical informed consent [ 47 ] are not consistent with such hypothesis. Interestingly, governing codes on disclosure of terminal illness to patients and families in Islamic countries vary considerably [ 48 ].…”

How parents and practitioners experience research without prior consent (deferred consent) for emergency research involving children with life threatening conditions: a mixed method study

“… 22 Deferred consent seemed to initially perturb some parents, who spoke of their momentary shock or anger when they first found out that their child had been entered into research without their prior knowledge and consent. 42 Many parents were surprised that the normal process of research information disclosure as part of an informed consent process could be changed and postponed in this way, 40 43 while a few suggested that their right as a parent to make an autonomous decision about research had or could have been taken away. 5 44 45 Practitioners did not describe these initial negative reactions from parents, suggesting that parents did not voice these concerns during recruitment discussions.…”

Ethical Issues in Chinese Aesthetic Surgery

“…More elder educated males are particularly sensitive regarding the disclosure of their confidential information [22]. Aesthetic-seeking patients trust their medical aesthetician.…”